Re: Fitzgibbon : Mon May 13, 2024 3:52 pm  

Wires71 wrote:

Since Vaughan or better than Vaughan?

In terms of his ability as a rugby player and impact on the game.. i would say better.

Re: Fitzgibbon : Mon May 13, 2024 4:30 pm  

morleys_deckchair wrote:

In terms of his ability as a rugby player and impact on the game.. i would say better.

I’m out of the love-in for Vaughan atm.
He needs to earn some merit.

I’ll see how he goes this weekend.
So at this time, if I could only keep one of them, I’d keep Fitzgibbon.

Re: Fitzgibbon : Mon May 13, 2024 5:29 pm  

I think that's harsh on Vaughan. Vaughan just keeps delivering the performances that are way, way, ahead of our other props such as Musgrove and Philbin et al. Fizgibbon is also an excellent signing.

My pack 'stars' are

Vaughan
Harrison
Fizgibbon
Crowther

Re: Fitzgibbon : Mon May 13, 2024 6:47 pm  

Wires71 wrote:

I think that's harsh on Vaughan. Vaughan just keeps delivering the performances that are way, way, ahead of our other props such as Musgrove and Philbin et al. Fizgibbon is also an excellent signing.

My pack 'stars' are

Vaughan
Harrison
Fizgibbon
Crowther

i would add Walker into there, who has on the whole, has been excellent.

Re: Fitzgibbon : Mon May 13, 2024 6:47 pm  

Wires71 wrote:

I think that's harsh on Vaughan. Vaughan just keeps delivering the performances that are way, way, ahead of our other props such as Musgrove and Philbin et al. Fizgibbon is also an excellent signing.

My pack 'stars' are

Vaughan
Harrison
Fizgibbon
Crowther

Currie and Nicholson are not far behind those 4

Re: Fitzgibbon : Mon May 13, 2024 6:53 pm  

Vaughan and Fitzgibbon are our best two Aussie forwards for ages.

But if you compare their first ten games for the club, Vaughan wins hands down. Vaughan's season and a half compared to Fitzgibbon's half a season and it's much closer.

Re: Fitzgibbon : Mon May 13, 2024 7:02 pm  

karetaker wrote:

Currie and Nicholson are not far behind those 4

It`s hard to believe how Crowther has progressed from his initial loan signing from Wakefield.

He had signed a deal with Castleford for this season, & wasn`t even getting into the Wakefield team who were bottom of the table.

With Cas and Wakefield vying to avoid relegation, Wakefield wanted him away from their squad and wouldn`t release him to Cas early, as it would strengthen their squad.

Hence he was loaned to us, we liked what he had to offer and paid Cas a modest fee to retain him here.

I can`t give the guy enough credit for the way he has fitted into playing us.

Well done Jordy.

Re: Fitzgibbon : Mon May 13, 2024 10:16 pm  

In the past Crowther is exactly the kind of player who would play like he is now but elsewhere, come to us on big money and get lazy a la Westerman, Holmes etc. I'm just glad he's building his hype here rather than us having to buy it.

Back on thread, Fitzgibbon is a leader in both mentality and physicality. Those crash balls on the half turn make me wince, only to see him smiling and calling the opposition something i suspect is unsavoury.

Re: Fitzgibbon : Tue May 14, 2024 11:50 am  

fez1 wrote:

Honey monster maybe!

Asotasi is the one that really gets me. He just took the p - or rather the £££.

Dave Allen was another..... that is best forgotten

Reminds me of the prop forward we labelled the crab, was Steve Hogan that guy? We've had a beach full of crabs in the past, so there will be other names given.

Re: Fitzgibbon : Tue May 14, 2024 1:48 pm  

If you carry on with nightmarish players I will have to bring out the human milk bottle…