Re: Christianity - on the way out? : Wed Nov 20, 2013 1:21 pm  

I was brought up going to church. I still go to church. God has nothing to do with it. My understanding of the bible as a book is that of many others that I know. I disregard the old testament as a Christian book. Christianity starts and ends with Jesus' teachings. Jesus wasn't the son of God, he, if anything, was a very intelligent man with the same ability as someone like Derren Brown. His teachings were about humanity treating each other fairly. That's it. The bible was written in a way to control the masses through fear.

I still go to church and take a Sunday school class to try and explain my version of understanding to the young people (without being too blunt).

When listening to a service, I look for moral teaching in the story. Sometimes there isn't any but most of the time there is. I usually disagree with the minister's theory but that is irrelevant. The main reason for most churches is nothing to do with religion but for a place for the community to meet and socialise. The congregation at my church is actually growing and is very healthy.

I can imagine that other churches are more formal and can't speak for them, but I know why I go.

Re: Christianity - on the way out? : Wed Nov 20, 2013 2:50 pm  

I'll pop along to church at Christmas, as usual, and sing some festive hymms, although they should probably rotate the story a bit, maybe go with Elf this year, or The Grinch, even Dickens would make a change.

Re: Christianity - on the way out? : Thu Nov 21, 2013 10:16 am  

I have a friend who is heavily involved in the local CofE (I'm not sure of his exact function he might be a warden or a lay preacher or something along those lines), he admitted to me that he sometimes envys Catholics because there isn't the same sort of confusion over what it wants to be that there is in Anglicanism. It would be wrong to believe that the Catholic Church is unwavering in its dogma, even if that's how it likes to portray itself, but it doesn't have this kind of multiple personality disorder that Anglicanism currently suffers from. There is a bit of a joke in local politics around here that vicars tend to be Lib Dems as there's a sort of soft, woolly liberalism about a lot of them, but I don't think that really goes well with people who do religion, if they do formal religion they want a degree of certainty in their belief and if they are following "spiritual" or "neo-pagan" type beliefs then they want the sort of flexibility and individualism that doesn't work with mainstream organised religion.

I have an article from bbk magazine (Issue 27, Spring 2010) by a Birkbeck academic called Eric Kaufmann which suggests that "whilst secularism continues to dominate high culture, its demographich disadvantage means it must run to stand still", or in a nutshell the religious are multiplying faster than the non-religious, which is not neccessarily of concern to anyone, except that the fundamentalists are the ones who tend to have the biggest families. He points to London as an example where religious participation overall is actually experiencing a revival on the back of immigration (but in particular from those groups who tend to have larger families like fundamentalist Muslims who have on average one child more than moderate Muslim families).

Re: Christianity - on the way out? : Sat Nov 23, 2013 7:53 am  

West Leeds Rhino wrote:

I was brought up going to church. I still go to church. God has nothing to do with it. My understanding of the bible as a book is that of many others that I know. I disregard the old testament as a Christian book. Christianity starts and ends with Jesus' teachings. Jesus wasn't the son of God, he, if anything, was a very intelligent man with the same ability as someone like Derren Brown. His teachings were about humanity treating each other fairly. That's it. The bible was written in a way to control the masses through fear.

I still go to church and take a Sunday school class to try and explain my version of understanding to the young people (without being too blunt).

When listening to a service, I look for moral teaching in the story. Sometimes there isn't any but most of the time there is. I usually disagree with the minister's theory but that is irrelevant. The main reason for most churches is nothing to do with religion but for a place for the community to meet and socialise. The congregation at my church is actually growing and is very healthy.

I can imagine that other churches are more formal and can't speak for them, but I know why I go.

You do realise mate that just as there is no God, there was nt a Jesus bloke either.
Are you happy knowing you are brain washing people into accepting your unfounded beliefs on others.
In my opinion, ALL preachers of ANY Religion should be jailed for at least spouting BS and at worse for brain washing.
Like smoking it should be banned for under 18s and then they can decide if they want to believe in your imaginary god/jesus/religion off their own back and not forced into it like those you preach to on sundays.

Here endeth the Sermon!!!

Re: Christianity - on the way out? : Sat Nov 23, 2013 9:47 am  

CORNISH wrote: You do realise mate that just as there is no God, there was nt a Jesus bloke either. Are you happy knowing you are brain washing people into accepting your unfounded beliefs on others. In my opinion, ALL preachers of ANY Religion should be jailed for at least spouting BS and at worse for brain washing. Like smoking it should be banned for under 18s and then they can decide if they want to believe in your imaginary god/jesus/religion off their own In all fairness, there is evidence that someone called Jesus existed. Historicity of Jesus.

CORNISH wrote: You do realise mate that just as there is no God, there was nt a Jesus bloke either. Are you happy knowing you are brain washing people into accepting your unfounded beliefs on others. In my opinion, ALL preachers of ANY Religion should be jailed for at least spouting BS and at worse for brain washing. Like smoking it should be banned for under 18s and then they can decide if they want to believe in your imaginary god/jesus/religion off their own In all fairness, there is evidence that someone called Jesus existed. Historicity of Jesus.

Re: Christianity - on the way out? : Sun Nov 24, 2013 8:25 am  

Mintball wrote: In all fairness, there is evidence that someone called Jesus existed. Historicity of Jesus. Just to play, erm, Devil's advocate ... To agree with the Christian philosophy, as purportedly preached by Jesus, doesn't require belief that he existed. A bit similar to liking Shakespeare, regardless of whether the Stratford chap actually wrote it.

Mintball wrote: In all fairness, there is evidence that someone called Jesus existed. Historicity of Jesus. Just to play, erm, Devil's advocate ... To agree with the Christian philosophy, as purportedly preached by Jesus, doesn't require belief that he existed. A bit similar to liking Shakespeare, regardless of whether the Stratford chap actually wrote it.

Re: Christianity - on the way out? : Mon Nov 25, 2013 7:40 am  

El Barbudo wrote:

Just to play, erm, Devil's advocate ...
To agree with the Christian philosophy, as purportedly preached by Jesus, doesn't require belief that he existed.
A bit similar to liking Shakespeare, regardless of whether the Stratford chap actually wrote it.

Oh, I appreciate that. But I was responding to a non-believer who claimed he didn't exist at all.

Which makes for certain amusing contrast.

Re: Christianity - on the way out? : Mon Nov 25, 2013 8:45 am  

I used to be a humanist, was brought up CofE but rejected it at a very young age, I was always a very inquisitive child and asked lots if questions at sunday school to a point were I was actually told I was a disruptive influence on the others. I've never thought that but I was always someone who strove for definitive answers which made religion a very hard sell for me. It's a similar reason I dropped psychology, to much theory not enough actual knowledge.

Now I'm not even a humanist, if we all disappeared off the earth it would be no bad thing.

Re: Christianity - on the way out? : Mon Nov 25, 2013 9:21 am  

Mystic Yed wrote:

Now I'm not even a humanist, if we all disappeared off the earth it would be no bad thing.

The planet would then be over-run with chickens.
with acknowledgement to Malcolm Lord

Re: Christianity - on the way out? : Mon Nov 25, 2013 9:29 am  

Mystic Yed wrote:

... if we all disappeared off the earth it would be no bad thing.

Think of all the extraordinary things that would disappear too: for the universe never to hear a Beethoven symphony again or see once more a Turner landscape or listen to see Shakespeare on a stage or marvel at the curves of a Moore sculpture.

And that's sticking to Western classical culture.

It's easy to feel pissy about the state of the world, but there have been – and continue to be – magnificent achievements; amazing heights attained.