Sal Paradise wrote:
The only people being demonised by the press are those that abuse the system - and they should be. We have more people on disability than ever despite falling manual labour and significantly better and more expensive health service. In better I mean more advanced drug treatments. It doesn't make logical sense.
What? How many people do you think that are on DLA have a disability that is curable?. The word "disability" is the key.
When you have benefits rising quicker than the minimum wage than something is wrong. If I lost my job I would most likely have to sell my house and move to cheaper area - so you can see why many get frustrated at the outrage that some might have to move because their benefits no longer allow them to continue living in London!!
You probably wouldn't need to sell your house. Certainly not right away. I am sure you not being a "shirker" would have not problem getting a new job anyway. I mean isn't part of your argument that the jobs are there if people would only get off their backside and look for them?
On the food - do we have people starving in this country? no we don't - how many of these who have to choose between heating and food continue to smoke and drink? You complain about paper sensationalising but you are doing exactly the same food banks are a minuscule element of our food supply chain.
So why do we have the need for food banks then?
On corporate tax - this is global issue, just like you banking crisis - unless it is sorted worldwide this will continue to happen. If large corporations didn't contribute I would agree but they do and you know that - if you took the value of taxation a Marks & Spencer's pays on employing people i.e. employers NI it will run into hundreds of millions - plus all the money that is pumped into the economy my those employees of M&S. After all you and Mr Fish are advocating greater public spending to stimulate the economy by creating jobs!! but you give no credit to those companies who do make massive contributions through the numbers they employ.
Not this rubbish again. The fact companies pay NI doesn't mean they are not expected to also pay corporation tax at the going rate. UK based companies can't avoid it, only the multi-nationals can but as has been pointed out many times this isn't just because it is an international problem but because HMRC is also too relaxed over the reliefs it grants for things like use of brand names and trade marks. There is far, far more money to be recouped by attacking the "tax gap" than there is in reducing benefits. It is something like 10 times the amount.
I have asked on here before but what do you think a living wage should be - if you push the minimum wage up then you need to reduce the tax burden on companies elsewhere, government will not need the levels of revenues. You are in effect moving further right with less government input into where the taxation monies are spent.
A living wage is supposed to be £7.45 an hour outside London £8.55 per hour in London. The current minimum wage is £6.19 if you are over 21. Supporters of the living wage include Boris Johnson and IDS (work should be seen to pay is what he said about it) and employers who pay it report less absenteeism, better recruitment and retention of staff and positive impact on their organisation as being seen as an ethical employer. Ed Milliband has suggested government contracts be giving to living wage employers in preference to those who don't pay it which seems like a very good idea.
Interestingly Cameron supported it in opposition but dropped it once he got in power not even paying the downing street cleaners the living wage. Paying it also reduces the benefits bill. Some companies
do already pay the living wage. Barclays. HSBC and KPMG do. A lot of councils do. The Holiday Inn chain in London does (and hotel work is a notoriously low paid sector) The Institute for Fiscal Studies says the treasury saves £1000 in benefits and tax credits for each living wage worker. The simple fact of the matter is the vast majority of firms can afford it.
