HS2 rail link : Tue Nov 15, 2016 1:03 pm  

thought this would be a good topic on here as it will run near to a lot of the posters and affect the lives of quite a few on here by the looks of it. the route for the northern leg of the project has just been announced though in typical fashion nothing has been set in stone yet. some details here what's everyone's thoughts on this? waste of money or a good investment. will anyone be affected by it either through demolitions or noise etc. do we really need to invest all this money to save less than an hour travel to london from leeds for example. will other services be cut to make this more affordable. will it simply mean more people from the north can go to london to work or will it attract much needed businesses to the north and make the so called northern powerhouse come to fruition. one of my problems with all of this is that it is assumed we are going to have a super railway where everything runs on time. when built no doubt there will still be leaves on the line, the wrong type of snow and staff shortages meaning the usual lengthy delays. overrunning engineering works and people shoehorned into inadequate length trains. and i dare not even think about ticker prices. just wish we could spend some money on the network where needed such as selby swing bridge which seems the be closed every year for one reason or another

thought this would be a good topic on here as it will run near to a lot of the posters and affect the lives of quite a few on here by the looks of it. the route for the northern leg of the project has just been announced though in typical fashion nothing has been set in stone yet. some details here what's everyone's thoughts on this? waste of money or a good investment. will anyone be affected by it either through demolitions or noise etc. do we really need to invest all this money to save less than an hour travel to london from leeds for example. will other services be cut to make this more affordable. will it simply mean more people from the north can go to london to work or will it attract much needed businesses to the north and make the so called northern powerhouse come to fruition. one of my problems with all of this is that it is assumed we are going to have a super railway where everything runs on time. when built no doubt there will still be leaves on the line, the wrong type of snow and staff shortages meaning the usual lengthy delays. overrunning engineering works and people shoehorned into inadequate length trains. and i dare not even think about ticker prices. just wish we could spend some money on the network where needed such as selby swing bridge which seems the be closed every year for one reason or another

Re: HS2 rail link : Tue Nov 15, 2016 1:23 pm  

From speaking to lots of people, my view on this is comfortably the less popular one in the North of England.
However, for me, infrastructure stuff is simple, we should have the best, up to date transport system that is available.
Following the logic of the "naysayers", we would still have a bloke with a red flag, walking in front of a train travelling at 7 mph.

Of course there has to be provision for many of the areas that will be disrupted but, like all these things, the objections come from those that are
directly affected and most people would also object if it war routed close to them or causing inconvenience.

At the risk of stoking up the Euro debate, we are well behind other developed nation with our rail system and the HS2 is a step in the right direction.

One thing that I would add, is that, England does seem too London centric in it's overall strategy and there is too much emphasis on centralising many of the country's larger businesses down there and perhaps there should be more effort made, as government policy, to move certain amenities into other parts of the UK.

They do have something called the "Northern Powerhouse" but, quite frankly, this just appears to be some kind of buzz word among politicians and there seems very little evidence of any kind of drive to help the North of England.

(I'll get my tin hat ready)

Re: HS2 rail link : Tue Nov 15, 2016 5:03 pm  

There was a thread on HS2 a while back.

Re: HS2 rail link : Wed Nov 16, 2016 1:13 pm  

Whilst continuous improvements in our infrastructure are needed, HS2 is yet another case of a huge investment aimed at benefitting London primarily.

Combine the estimated costs (£55.7bn for HS2), plus Crossrail (£14.8bn), London Gateway (£1.5bn) and the new runway at Heathrow (£18.6bn) - that comes to a total of £90.6bn. That's just 4 projects.

What have we got going on up North? Well, the A64 got some pot holes filled in a couple of years ago.

Investment in infrastructure = great! But make sure that the levels of investment are fair.

Re: HS2 rail link : Wed Nov 16, 2016 2:03 pm  

DGM wrote:

Whilst continuous improvements in our infrastructure are needed, HS2 is yet another case of a huge investment aimed at benefitting London primarily.

Combine the estimated costs (£55.7bn for HS2), plus Crossrail (£14.8bn), London Gateway (£1.5bn) and the new runway at Heathrow (£18.6bn) - that comes to a total of £90.6bn. That's just 4 projects.

What have we got going on up North? Well, the A64 got some pot holes filled in a couple of years ago.

Investment in infrastructure = great! But make sure that the levels of investment are fair.

Don't forget the Thameslink Programme(£6bn), scheduled for completion 2018, the likely development of Crossrail 2 ( £27–32 billion, at 2014 prices) and the East London Line Extensions completed in 2010 at a cost of £1bn. London and the South East are worth it. The North has , after all, been promised the £0.6bn Northern Hub which is more than a fair share of this capital investment, I'm sure anyone would agree.

[Bullseye]

Re: HS2 rail link : Wed Nov 16, 2016 3:50 pm  

Wait until inflation affects those figures.

Re: HS2 rail link : Wed Nov 16, 2016 5:50 pm  

I'd be less skeptical if work started in the North with HS3. Connect Liverpool to Hull and take in as many major cities in between, a kind of M62 on rails. As I see it the HS2 money will 'run out' once London is connected to Birmingham, essentially making Birmingham London's biggest commuter village and further sucking the life out of the rest of the country.

Re: HS2 rail link : Wed Nov 16, 2016 7:39 pm  

The line from Selby to Hull will not be electrified Northern Powerhouse Northern chugchugchugonthepacertrainwiththebusseatshouse more like

The line from Selby to Hull will not be electrified Northern Powerhouse Northern chugchugchugonthepacertrainwiththebusseatshouse more like

Re: HS2 rail link : Thu Nov 17, 2016 10:59 am  

DGM wrote:

What have we got going on up North? Well, the A64 got some pot holes filled in a couple of years ago.

3 years of roadworks on the M1/M62 - to add another lane, which will be just as full of cars and trucks as the other lanes?

Re: HS2 rail link : Thu Nov 17, 2016 11:14 am  

DGM wrote:
What have we got going on up North? Well, the A64 got some pot holes filled in a couple of years ago.


3 years of roadworks on the M1/M62 - to add another lane, which will be just as full of cars and trucks as the other lanes?

But not as full as original lanes would have been without it- correct? But hey let's not consider that. We are the hard done northerners