Re: Rovers : Sat Feb 26, 2022 10:56 pm  

Ohmetoe wrote:

Sorry but With everything else going on in the world a game of rugby league doesnt seem very interesting or relevant . Fev to win but nobody is all that bothered

Relatively speaking very likely true but more negativity like your post hardly helps and if others think a game of rugby league does help then that’s up to them and why not.

Re: Rovers : Sat Feb 26, 2022 11:24 pm  

faxcar wrote:

Well these 2 years your talking about have been 2 years of covid related reduced revenues.

Maybe you could come up with the 50 grand plus per season that it costs to run the reserves and provide the players of sufficient number and quality to make it worth the effort and expense because that is exactly what your proposing and asking others to do, talk is cheap, reality is not.

And back on thread and back to the real world, tough game tomorrow against quality opposition but these are the games both supporters and players look forward to and are focussed on.

But that’s just my opinion. Up the Fax and a nice cup of tea.

Obviously I don't have £50,000 a year. The reserves were funded partly with funds raised by the supporters club of which I regularly contributed to. I'm not asking anyone to do owt at all just pointing out that Halifax RLFC should be just that and not a joint venture with any other club. If I can contribute in my small way I will do and it is up to others to choose how they support our club.

Re: Rovers : Sat Feb 26, 2022 11:57 pm  

Hudd-Shay wrote:

Obviously I don't have £50,000 a year. The reserves were funded partly with funds raised by the supporters club of which I regularly contributed to. I'm not asking anyone to do owt at all just pointing out that Halifax RLFC should be just that and not a joint venture with any other club. If I can contribute in my small way I will do and it is up to others to choose how they support our club.

I am fully aware of how the funds were raised and who did it and as many, if not all on here personally contributed but there will be many who are struggling financially owing to the impact of covid.
Clearly the period running up to 2 years ago things were vastly different.
The reality of now is Fax, acting responsibly have had to readjust to the current situation just like we all have and simply can not afford to run a reserve team that you did propose and in effect ask for.

At every level Fax are a fully independent club and as such the BoD have the right to choose what arrangements they enter into regarding the running and management of the club.

To have a mutually beneficial reserves arrangement does not change their independence rather because it’s their decision actually confirms it.

Likewise any personal objections or opinions we may have on DR or loans has no relevance whatsoever to any clubs independence.

Re: Rovers : Sun Feb 27, 2022 12:36 am  

faxcar wrote:

I am fully aware of how the funds were raised and who did it and as many, if not all on here personally contributed but there will be many who are struggling financially owing to the impact of covid.
Clearly the period running up to 2 years ago things were vastly different.
The reality of now is Fax, acting responsibly have had to readjust to the current situation just like we all have and simply can not afford to run a reserve team that you did propose and in effect ask for.

At every level Fax are a fully independent club and as such the BoD have the right to choose what arrangements they enter into regarding the running and management of the club.

To have a mutually beneficial reserves arrangement does not change their independence rather because it’s their decision actually confirms it.

Likewise any personal objections or opinions we may have on DR or loans has no relevance whatsoever to any clubs independence.

To use Dual Registration and have an 'arrangement' regarding players is hardly being independent in my book.

Re: Rovers : Sun Feb 27, 2022 9:07 am  

faxcar wrote:

I am fully aware of how the funds were raised and who did it and as many, if not all on here personally contributed but there will be many who are struggling financially owing to the impact of covid.
Clearly the period running up to 2 years ago things were vastly different.
The reality of now is Fax, acting responsibly have had to readjust to the current situation just like we all have and simply can not afford to run a reserve team that you did propose and in effect ask for.

At every level Fax are a fully independent club and as such the BoD have the right to choose what arrangements they enter into regarding the running and management of the club.

To have a mutually beneficial reserves arrangement does not change their independence rather because it’s their decision actually confirms it.

Likewise any personal objections or opinions we may have on DR or loans has no relevance whatsoever to any clubs independence.

Wouldn't waste your time mate. He'll never grasp it.

Re: Rovers : Sun Feb 27, 2022 9:20 am  

Any road, game day is here and at last a bit of sunshine. The pitch will be heavy but I'd have both Walmsley and Jouffret in the side. If we try to just stifle Fev we will get the same result as we did against Widnes, we've got to go for it and if we can rid ourselves of the daft mistakes and poor discipline we are more than capable of reaching the next round. Let's just hope though that the officials are better than those from last night's boxing match. Up The Fax❗

Re: Rovers : Sun Feb 27, 2022 9:49 am  

Hudd-Shay wrote:

To use Dual Registration and have an 'arrangement' regarding players is hardly being independent in my book.

Well you need a new book and one with more than the same old one line in it that never fits the the thread or current subject matter.

The first post about Roberts not being in the squad said this.

Quote:"Ah, no Roberts, surprise, surprise. It just goes to show the idiocy of DR. He was in last weeks squad and therefore presumably trained with us. Giants don't allow him to be in this weeks squad so training without him. What a waste of time."

When the simple answer has nothing to do with DR but not wanting him cup tied, everybody knows it and understood why except you.

Your book, with no DR, Loans and in the current situation would have the likes of Ben Tibbs just sat around stagnating week after week as in this post.
Quote: "Merged reserves? Whatever next? Utter madness! "

And this.
Quote:"I wonder what our own players think of the situation?"

I wonder how Ben Tibbs or others would feel then when they had a chance for some game time but you would be saying NO.

Re: Rovers : Sun Feb 27, 2022 12:01 pm  

While I hope both Walmsley and Jouffret get a run once the pitches dry out, wouldn't play Walmsley today as I think he would struggle with the size of either Briscoe or Gale. May sound a bit negative but having been dropped for perceived defensive frailties against Batley , big risk both to team performance and players confidence to throw him back in against best ream in the league. I'm looking forward to today - just hope the underdogs tag inspires the team to put in a performance.

Re: Rovers : Sun Feb 27, 2022 12:22 pm  

Ilkley Fax wrote:

While I hope both Walmsley and Jouffret get a run once the pitches dry out, wouldn't play Walmsley today as I think he would struggle with the size of either Briscoe or Gale. May sound a bit negative but having been dropped for perceived defensive frailties against Batley , big risk both to team performance and players confidence to throw him back in against best ream in the league. I'm looking forward to today - just hope the underdogs tag inspires the team to put in a performance.

Yes, plenty of questions on how SG approaches this one.
With Martin being cup tied there has to be a change, so who will go to 1.
The back 3 went well against Widnes so will he want to change that around a bit and have Salty in there?
Will it be Jouffret?
Walmsley will have to play sooner or later, would it be better in a cup tie?
Anyway a cracking day weather wise and after last week the East Standers will need their sunglasses instead of sou'westers!!

Re: Rovers : Sun Feb 27, 2022 12:55 pm  

Walmsley needs to start at fullback Today.