: Tue Aug 18, 2009 3:38 pm  

ParanoidAndroid wrote:

Give over, if Goldy went now, some other player (not any of the 'local' lads mind) would cop it if we lost. He is playing no better or no worse than the majority of the team but I don't see other threads with them getting lambasted?

no mate they wouldnt cop it from me at any rate, mcgoldrick is the only one who goes out there week on week makes the same mistakes has the i dont give a to$$ attitude and keeps on getting picked, thats my issue here there maybe other players in the team who are not as good as others in super league but at least they are giving it 100% every week and that is all you can ask for, so no there would be no others just him.

: Tue Aug 18, 2009 4:25 pm  

poppys mum wrote:

Do you know summat guys.
All we had to do in may when sherwin was injured, was get a loan scrum half in from NL1.

Then we could have left goldy at full back where he was playing very well and in a settled position.
Owen could have stayed on the wing, imo hes a winger not a FB.
Rangi chase at 6
New loan player at 7
Instead we struggled on playing players out of position, and imo ryan mcgoldrick is the one that as suffered the most.

Agree completely:CLAP: Remember RMc was player of the year last year!!!

: Tue Aug 18, 2009 4:32 pm  

jungle man wrote:

Agree completely:CLAP: Remember RMc was player of the year last year!!!

He was one poor last year.

: Wed Aug 19, 2009 2:50 pm  

its the coach ,s fault he moves players all over the pitch ie widders at stand off, rather than picking a player from the lower grades like every other team does

: Wed Aug 19, 2009 7:35 pm  

supercas wrote:

its the coach ,s fault he moves players all over the pitch ie widders at stand off, rather than picking a player from the lower grades like every other team does

You touch on a good point there. We do seem to be reluctant to put players in from the lower grades, why on earth is that? Is it that much of a risk?

Ryan is class and he does put the effort in. Got to say he'd be my first choicw centre with Shenny, but then Evans has been resigned so I guess he'll be continuing at fullback, stand off, loose forward, etc. Its a Joke, no wonder his form has suffered.