Re: Leaving : Tue Sep 14, 2010 2:52 pm  

Sad to see them go, but it had to be done really.

Re: Leaving : Tue Sep 14, 2010 3:41 pm  

Winky is a loss,would make a decent squad player but he is a bit dodgey under attacking kicks. Higgins was nothing special,Clayton,for me wont be missed.

Re: Leaving : Tue Sep 14, 2010 4:39 pm  

Thank god Clayton has gone

Although, if last year (might have been the year before) is anything to go by, we might sign him back as there is "nobody else to sign"

Re: Leaving : Tue Sep 14, 2010 7:54 pm  

Sad to see all three go, particularly Snowie. All three have put in 100% and I sincerely wish them all the best in the future.

Re: Leaving : Tue Sep 21, 2010 10:19 am  

pyeman wrote:

I know its become fashonable to blame mcgoldrick for all our problems (just as it was with sherwin) but i feel he cops alot of unjustified flack. He does make errors but these have become more in frequant and he is a big attacking threat.

I wonder if mathers and youngquest, two players who have a habit of making errors and costing tries will cop as much flack?

Well said. I don't see why he gets so much stick either. He is involved in a lot of tries, and we have far worse players on the team.

Re: Leaving : Tue Sep 21, 2010 10:39 am  

goldy gets stick because he is a very talented player but, he is a beer monster , has a poor attitude and tries when he feels like it. He can tackle but he doesnt really want to so he doesnt bother....... why would you when you can still get 100k a year and do what ever you want (on or off the field) managed properly he would be superleagues best back .

Re: Leaving : Tue Sep 21, 2010 11:51 am  

tttiger wrote:

goldy gets stick because he is a very talented player but, he is a beer monster , has a poor attitude and tries when he feels like it. He can tackle but he doesnt really want to so he doesnt bother....... why would you when you can still get 100k a year and do what ever you want (on or off the field) managed properly he would be superleagues best back .

I agree with this bit...but to say that under proper management he would be superleagues best back is a massive stretch, the talents there to be a good player, and it shows (at times), but he doesn't possess the talent to be amazing IMO.