: Sat May 16, 2009 10:51 am  

agree with spuda 100%

ive never ben his biggest fan but have NEVER booeed a player while they are wearing a cas shirt and NEVER will.

sione is more than an average player as he has shown last night and when he was the linchpin of the 50 point hammerings of fev and salford

: Sat May 16, 2009 11:31 am  

Chase made an embarrassing debut IMO and was the worst player on the park that day. Has obviously got used to SL and played well last night.

: Sat May 16, 2009 3:37 pm  

tropical1 wrote:

agree with spuda 100%


sione is more than an average player as he has shown last night and when he was the linchpin of the 50 point hammerings of fev and salford

If I can get used to having my heart in my mouth every time he goes near the ball then maybe i'll grow to appreciate him

At the moment though he's still not good enough.

: Sat May 16, 2009 3:46 pm  

Tigerpie wrote:

If I can get used to having my heart in my mouth every time he goes near the ball then maybe i'll grow to appreciate him

At the moment though he's still not good enough.

im sure sione would agree with you aswell that he hasnt been playing to the best of his ability. But to boo him is wrong, he is still a cas player at end of day and its taking time to get used to playing super league, We have heard it all before about vowles taking time to settle into life at cas look how he turned out (legend)

I undertsand that theres the other side of the coin with rudder/korkidas/greenhill etc could even say sherwin last season (been immense this season after poeple knocked him last year) but at least sione looks like he is trying to play, he may throw silly passes out but at least its a sign that he is trying to makew things happen non of the above ever looked like doing anything for us!

we all know that sione has had problems and all he needs is to settle down into the cas team and im positive he will become a greaat asset to the cas team!

I just wish people would give him a chance! I know i will....

Ohh and by the way chase deserved motm!!!!

: Sat May 16, 2009 4:15 pm  

spuda wrote:

im sure sione would agree with you aswell that he hasnt been playing to the best of his ability. But to boo him is wrong, he is still a cas player at end of day and its taking time to get used to playing super league, We have heard it all before about vowles taking time to settle into life at cas look how he turned out (legend)

I undertsand that theres the other side of the coin with rudder/korkidas/greenhill etc could even say sherwin last season (been immense this season after poeple knocked him last year) but at least sione looks like he is trying to play, he may throw silly passes out but at least its a sign that he is trying to makew things happen non of the above ever looked like doing anything for us!

we all know that sione has had problems and all he needs is to settle down into the cas team and im positive he will become a greaat asset to the cas team!

I just wish people would give him a chance! I know i will....

Ohh and by the way chase deserved motm!!!!

sherwin was only half fit last season since his op were seeing the best of him

: Sat May 16, 2009 5:23 pm  

sgtwilko wrote:

bit of a blinkered view!! buderus was the best defender on the field

yes he played ok but he still got played of the park and Chase did not have a breather he is an up comming player un like Danny who had is day 4 years ago.

: Sun May 17, 2009 12:02 am  

sgtwilko wrote:

bit of a blinkered view!! buderus was the best defender on the field

But Chase was by far the best attacking, setting up Dixon's try and scoring one superb effort by himself. Failure to recognise that on your part makes you look a little blinkered yourself. Do think before you post, please.

: Sun May 17, 2009 12:04 am  

Fully wrote:

But Chase was by far the best attacking, setting up Dixon's try and scoring one superb effort by himself. Failure to recognise that on your part makes you look a little blinkered yourself. Do think before you post, please.

yes for sure! i thought he was awesome!!

: Sun May 17, 2009 12:14 am  

sgtwilko wrote:

yes for sure! i thought he was awesome!!

Out of Diskin, Buderus and Chase he was. Seriously, are you a 14-year-old kid or just deluded? I'm trying to figure out which but I'm really struggling.

I'm not even being biased here. I generally thought that the result was fair on measure of it, on the basis of your superb defensive effort.

I thought had it stayed at 22-all then yes, OK, it would probably still have been a fair result. 24-22 I can accept because both sides put in an enormous amount of effort given the conditions, and that was a superb game of rugby? Can you see footballers playing in the same venom, speed or quality in those conditions? No. It was a superb advent for our game, and shows the level that SL is reaching

There were errors for both sides in terms of refereeing. I recall two errors made in front of our sticks by us in the 2nd half that went uncalled for, and probably would have resulted in Leeds tries. That said, there were mistakes vis-a-vis that went against us, and more than likely SHOULD have been picked up for.

: Sun May 17, 2009 12:20 am  

sgtwilko wrote:

bit of a blinkered view!! buderus was the best defender on the field

Yes I'm sure that's the reason Leeds are paying him loads of wonga.