: Sat Aug 15, 2009 8:36 pm  

who needs flankers? wrote:

Think u can add Shenny to that list too. Gives it his all every week!

Yeah I would say so but he is being made to look bad having to defend about 8 men and hardly ever gets ball in attack.

Another Plea is TM gona pick a side for shenton to play and leave him there rather swapping sides every week

: Sun Aug 16, 2009 9:45 am  

philukleeds wrote:

Yeah I would say so but he is being made to look bad having to defend about 8 men and hardly ever gets ball in attack.

Another Plea is TM gona pick a side for shenton to play and leave him there rather swapping sides every week

i think thats been the thing holding shenton back this season, i dont really look at the opta stats but he must make more tackles per game than any other Centre in the league couple that with the service he gets from goldy and thats the only reason he isnt without doubt the top Centre in super league, but thats just my opinion.

: Sun Aug 16, 2009 9:57 am  

I think shenton has had a good season.
He's had a couple of bad games, but then all the team had a pretty much bad game against Leeds.

He's scored more tries than any centre in superleague this year. And has looked superb in a lot of matches.

If you compare his stats against other centres than he pretty much comes out on top. I'd say the only English centre better than him this year is Senior, but shenton is only 22.

: Sun Aug 16, 2009 11:24 am  

Another stupid post. Do you honestly think this will help a player that is obviously struggling with confidence due to playing out of position?

Call yourself supporters

: Sun Aug 16, 2009 12:50 pm  

Riggins wrote:

Another stupid post. Do you honestly think this will help a player that is obviously struggling with confidence due to playing out of position?

Call yourself supporters

sorry mate everyone has there opinion but i have to disagree with yours, you tell me what position you have seen mcgoldrick play well in, we have seen him at fullback, Centre,standoff, and loose the truth is he dosent have a position and since he got his new contract he is just pinching money, i will agree with one of your points though this is a pointless pole as it will make no difference to anything he will still keep getting in the team every week and will still kepp giving sub standard performances but thats just the way it is i am affraid.

: Sun Aug 16, 2009 1:05 pm  

Riggins wrote:

Another stupid post. Do you honestly think this will help a player that is obviously struggling with confidence due to playing out of position?

Call yourself supporters

correct

: Sun Aug 16, 2009 2:14 pm  

tigerman10 wrote:

sorry mate everyone has there opinion but i have to disagree with yours, you tell me what position you have seen mcgoldrick play well in, we have seen him at fullback, Centre,standoff, and loose the truth is he dosent have a position and since he got his new contract he is just pinching money, i will agree with one of your points though this is a pointless pole as it will make no difference to anything he will still keep getting in the team every week and will still kepp giving sub standard performances but thats just the way it is i am affraid.

.

Correct everyone has there opinions, but do you really thinking this helps a player. No a chance. We are called supporters so lets start supporting.

: Sun Aug 16, 2009 2:24 pm  

Riggins wrote:

.

Correct everyone has there opinions, but do you really thinking this helps a player. No a chance. We are called supporters so lets start supporting.

Yes we are called supporters and he is called a player on a big wage. Does that mean he is not able to be called out by supporters who pay there hard earned cash every week to go watch the team play and for him to put sub par after sub par performances each week.

Would we get away with it on our jobs no we would get a kick up booty or fired. what does he get a place in team every week without fail. In my opinion he is robbing the clubs and fans blind week in week out and deserve all the crap he gets into he puts in performances like he is supposed too.

: Sun Aug 16, 2009 3:44 pm  

Riggins wrote:

.

Correct everyone has there opinions, but do you really thinking this helps a player. No a chance. We are called supporters so lets start supporting.

cant accept that mate, i support the team as much as anyone i have missed one game in the last 3 seasons and that was because i had to go to wedding and sky fcuked me, as i have said earlier i dont like knocking players but this guy is not strugling for form he is just not interested as he knows his spot in the team is reserved week in week out irelevant of performance, some people on this forum must have blinkers on if they cant see mcgoldrick couldnt give a to$$ when he goes out there as he does the same thing week on week either interception balls or hospital balls and i just think its about time somthing was done about it before he stuffs up our season once and for all, oh and this post hasnt just come on a whim after fridays game in which very few came out of it with any sort of credit, this has been coming over the full season or to be more precise since he got his new contract.

: Sun Aug 16, 2009 4:31 pm  

tigerman10 wrote:

cant accept that mate, i support the team as much as anyone i have missed one game in the last 3 seasons and that was because i had to go to wedding and sky fcuked me, as i have said earlier i dont like knocking players but this guy is not strugling for form he is just not interested as he knows his spot in the team is reserved week in week out irelevant of performance, some people on this forum must have blinkers on if they cant see mcgoldrick couldnt give a to$$ when he goes out there as he does the same thing week on week either interception balls or hospital balls and i just think its about time somthing was done about it before he stuffs up our season once and for all, oh and this post hasnt just come on a whim after fridays game in which very few came out of it with any sort of credit, this has been coming over the full season or to be more precise since he got his new contract.

Well said absolutely agree 150% as like my previous post how many points has he cost us with his hospital passes etx and his poor defence reading at fb or ambling back to a kick and getting caught behind line.

As my previous post said he need to be dropped. Cas have given him his pension for retirement with the 4 year deal. I myself have only missed 2 games home and away this year and have seen his performances get worse and worse. He does not care we should give someone a chance who will play for the badge.