Re: Richie Mathers : Tue Jul 06, 2010 6:37 pm  

The Chin's Back wrote:

In regards to the best ever free signing by any club,imo Jamie Peacock would take some beating!
Wigan paid £450,000 for Fielden and we got JP for nowt!

When you compare both JP and Fielden, the transfer fee Wigan payed looks even more ridiculous when you look at the pairs careers over the last 5 or so years.

Re: Richie Mathers : Tue Jul 06, 2010 6:40 pm  

Gurus_Beard wrote:

No, I really don't care if you beat Warrington.

You obviously have, given your position.

That really makes no sense, does it.

You don't seem to care much about Cas do you ?

Remind me why you are trolling our board every minute of the day again ?

Re: Richie Mathers : Tue Jul 06, 2010 6:45 pm  

Has Gaslight bin sniffing glue again.

Riley is better then Wainwright (look at the tries stats) -

Agree on this one, would rather have Riley than Wainwright

Atkins is better then Evans and Shenton (compare stats) -

That's because Atkins plays for a side in the top 2 whereas Shenny plays for one in 8th (which is why stats are better, Atkins plays with far better players at the side of him to feed him the ball and gets more chances. Shenton could easily be at a big club he just wants to stay with Cas at the minute)

Briers is one of best readers of the game/cleverist and still one of the best halfbacks in SL. -

True

Grix is a decent versatile squad player who would walk into a Cas team -

Wouldn't walk into our side at all

Harrison is alot better than Westerman, future star is this kid, wait and see -

Of course he is, tell me again who's been sniffing glue ? That said i'm sure in Warrington it's classed as normal.

Solomona is probably one of the best free signings of the decade, changes a game on his own, best readers and offloader in the game. Sheer strength, power and creativity to boot. -

No chance is he "one of the best"

Higham is alot better than Hudson - very good impact hooker and learning of one of the best in Monas. -
Toss up. When Hudson is on form he's as good if not better

Re: Richie Mathers : Tue Jul 06, 2010 7:07 pm  

LewisJ23 wrote:

Remind me why I bite at your posts every minute of the day again?

Edited for accuracy.

Re: Richie Mathers : Tue Jul 06, 2010 7:40 pm  

This is getting boring. Can't we just settle it this way?

Warrington fans think they have a team of superstars and are biased towards their own players.

Cas think they have a good mix of youth and some quality players that are better than players from other teams and are rightly biased towards their own.

Much easier and that way everyone gets on.

Re: Richie Mathers : Tue Jul 06, 2010 7:45 pm  

Wires 2 nd in the league...
cass............. hang on

wires have the better players.
End of .

Re: Richie Mathers : Tue Jul 06, 2010 7:56 pm  

Fully wrote:

This is getting boring. Can't we just settle it this way?

Warrington fans think they have a team of superstars and are biased towards their own players.

Cas think they have a good mix of youth and some quality players that are better than players from other teams and are rightly biased towards their own.

Much easier and that way everyone gets on.

Just ask the how many home grown 1st teamers do they have in their team

Re: Richie Mathers : Tue Jul 06, 2010 9:18 pm  

the ditch wrote:

Wires 2 nd in the league...
cass............. hang on

wires have the better players.
End of .

And that point contributes in whatsoever to this thread? No one disputed the fact that Warrington had a more consistent and overall better 13 than Cas but we're disputing that some individuals from Cas would make it into the Warrington team.

Re: Richie Mathers : Tue Jul 06, 2010 9:21 pm  

Fully wrote:

And that point contributes in whatsoever to this thread? .

Warrington think they're a big team all of a sudden and like to brag about this fact, see Huddersfield 10 week ago for an example.

Re: Richie Mathers : Tue Jul 06, 2010 9:28 pm  

Gaslight wrote:

Warrington think they're a big team all of a sudden and like to brag about this fact, see Huddersfield 10 week ago for an example.

Warrington have always been the perennial underachievers. But I can understand them getting excited. They are going through probably their brightest period in the Super League era and they do have a mouth-watering team from 1-17 and beyond.

But they need to stop viewing some of those players as world-class and start seeing that key individuals bring out the best in the other players. I'm pretty sure the likes of Shenton, Owen, Chase, Westerman, possibly even Huby too would flourish under the guidance of a world-class coach like Tony Smith and no doubt benefit from playing with quality players too.