Re: Tonights game : Sun Feb 14, 2010 12:15 am  

Asgardian13 wrote:

Very marginal incidents that hardly constituted offences. Thaler got this mostly right, though he did give a penalty against Morley. Worst 'offence' of the night was McGoldrick striking out at King just 'cause he got tackled in goal - far worse than Morley or Carvell.

Ridiculously partisan.

Re: Tonights game : Sun Feb 14, 2010 12:18 am  

Gaslight wrote:

Only seen it once, but with the McGoldrick/King incident watch where Kings hand goes, on the first viewing it looked a lot like Kings hand went straight towards McGoldricks crotch, which on top of being pinned up on the side of your neck would wind you up quite a lot.

Same old wanky wanky wire .

Re: Tonights game : Sun Feb 14, 2010 12:34 am  

Castleford gave the game to Warrington, simple really.

Too many little decisions went Warrington way.

Good effort Cas, hope you do well this season. Any chance we could sign Westerman off you please ?

Re: Tonights game : Sun Feb 14, 2010 8:02 am  

Gaslight wrote:

Only seen it once, but with the McGoldrick/King incident watch where Kings hand goes, on the first viewing it looked a lot like Kings hand went straight towards McGoldricks crotch, which on top of being pinned up on the side of your neck would wind you up quite a lot.

Give over, McGoldrick spends half the game niggling and winding up other players, then whinges when he gets it back, try watching it with you're eyes open. He does more harm than good for Cas.

Re: Tonights game : Sun Feb 14, 2010 8:49 am  

the_grobs wrote:

Firstly, the positives - Cas had a strong game, defence at many times of the game was superb, as was comittment and fitness levels. A lot that Cas can build on from here

Now the OK's, but in need of improvement.....our kicking game basically. Not creative enough, not accurate enough, often too flat so the guys couldn't get onto the ball with forward momentum to bowl over stationary opposition. Hudson...by no means bad, but he just didn't seem to be tuned in. He just wasn't all that lively, sharp and had a glazed look in his eyes.

Now the bad....what can I say...Thaler. Nothing positive about Thaler at all tonight, not that Ian Smith helped him at all as video ref. For those who went to the game and also recorded it. Watch for the Carvell head lunge into Huby's chin 34 seconds into the game. It's not quite a head butt...however he lunges his head towards Huby's face in the tackle, he was obviously well wound up. 3 minutes later the elbow into Jackson's face was disgracefull, more so by Thaler for doing absolutely nothing despite the stoppage of the game giving ample time to consider and to communicate the right action.....he didn't even speak to Carvell, to advise of his technique.

The Morley, elbow drop onto McGoldrick....again a disgusting reaction by Morley, at least a sin bin required. 10 minutes later the late/high tackle by Morley on Sherwin. It wasn't a matter of 'already being committed to the tackle!!' If Sherwin had kept the ball, Morley's arm wa still way to high for a legal tackle. Again, there's no excuse for it, and again Thaler having warned Morley for the elbow issue a few minutes earlier failed to take sufficient action.

Matt King. Watch the 69th minute when Matt King is tackled by Liam Higgins. When King gets up from the tackle he goes looking for Higgins after playing the ball. Higgins being one of the cleanest players in the game, just gets on with the game and jogs away.

3 minutes later, King still wound up, is involved with McGoldrick. McGoldrick, (who had a good game!!) no doubt should not have lashed out at King. However, McGoldrick seems to be taking exception to his body position in the tackle. His legs are up in the air with his weight on the side of his neck. No excuse for lashing out, however it's not a good position to be in with the weight of 2 players then on top of you. Hence the frustration, especially after the Morley elbow incident a few minutes earlier.

All in all, a good performance by Cas. Wires, as a top 3 rated team, were not special in any way. Thaler got it wrong, way to many times!!!... he also failed to take action, failed to communicate with the players and completely lost the plot and lost control of the game at times. A draw might well have been a fair result. I left the game, not at all disheartened by Cas....just disappointed with the way the game was / wasn't reffed!

Ouch..... the grapes are particularly sour in West Yorkshire it would appear.

You lost, get over it. Your line speed in defence was the stand out part of your game (more in the first half) but your execution of plays wasn't good enough (the words of Terry Matterson just in case your wondering) and thats why you lost. You can sit and analyse the game with your finger on the pause button to your hearts content, blaiming shots by Morley, Carvell etc blah blah blah, as well as Thaler, but its pointless.

Its a good job your coach doesn't share your bitter views against a team that deserved to beat you or your team would never progress in SL.

Re: Tonights game : Sun Feb 14, 2010 9:35 am  

I was happy with commitment from the start to finish, just a few little school boy error's which led to us losing the game. Our fitness and defence looks very impressive, a massive improvement on last year! I dont think we'll be far away this year, once we cut the little error's.

Warrington will be a very hard to team to beat this year.

Ive always been a McGoldrick fan, good servant to the club etc + not a bad player. Last night i thought, he looked disinterested, out of place + definatly not upto SL standard

Re: Tonights game : Sun Feb 14, 2010 9:36 am  

had you pants pulled down from Thaler

Re: Tonights game : Sun Feb 14, 2010 9:38 am  

[quote="Asgardian13"]Very marginal incidents that hardly constituted offences. Thaler got this mostly right, though he did give a penalty against Morley. Worst 'offence' of the night was McGoldrick striking out at King just 'cause he got tackled in goal - far worse than Morley or Carvell.[/quote]

load of drap...Morley took Sherwins head off

Re: Tonights game : Sun Feb 14, 2010 9:40 am  

pedro17 wrote:

had you pants pulled down from Thaler

Is that why Cas got 50% more penalties than Warrington?

Re: Tonights game : Sun Feb 14, 2010 10:28 am  

We lost because we made two crucial errors that lead to Warrington tries. End of. Otherwise it was a very very close game.

Both Carvells and Morleys incident are very poor indeed and suspensions are due. The flare up with McGoldrick and King was hand bags in a tense game.

Both sides showed lots of positives and Cas must learn to tighten up at key moments.

Major point for me is that one of the best fullbacks in the league is on our wing. That must be changed IMO