: Sat May 23, 2009 4:53 pm  

xJAMIEx wrote:

He was shocking. How on earth did he fail to miss that on Dixon in mid air when sherwin put the kick to the corner. Shocking decision.
Kr were constantly offside but never got punished for it.

You were offside in nearly every play.

You didn't notice the very late, headshot on Welham which was as bad as some I have seen players walk for.

The late hit on Dobson after he had kicked on the 5th (the player had lots of room to stop).

we could go on playing tit for tat, i doubt any team is completely innocent for a full 80 mins.

: Sat May 23, 2009 5:03 pm  

rover49 wrote:

You were offside in nearly every play.

You didn't notice the very late, headshot on Welham which was as bad as some I have seen players walk for.

The late hit on Dobson after he had kicked on the 5th (the player had lots of room to stop).

we could go on playing tit for tat, i doubt any team is completely innocent for a full 80 mins.

The Dixon decision inparticular was inexcusable. Really, really surprised that some of your fans are banging on about the ref when quite clearly all the 50/50's and more went your way. I say some KR fans because I was in town after chatting to a few of your lot and they were quick to admit the home crowd were reffing the game.
I'll go back to the particular Dixon incident because at that point we were on top and there was only 4 points in it.
The decision unbelieveably goes your way, then you get a penalty and go up the other end and score which completely turns the game.
Not the first time this season we have had game changing decisions go against us.

: Sat May 23, 2009 5:08 pm  

xJAMIEx wrote:

The Dixon decision inparticular was inexcusable. Really, really surprised that some of your fans are banging on about the ref when quite clearly all the 50/50's and more went your way. I say some KR fans because I was in town after chatting to a few of your lot and they were quick to admit the home crowd were reffing the game.
I'll go back to the particular Dixon incident because at that point we were on top and there was only 4 points in it.
The decision unbelieveably goes your way, then you get a penalty and go up the other end and score which completely turns the game.
Not the first time this season we have had game changing decisions go against us.

You keep going on about the Dixon incident, the player who decked Welham should have walked, which DEFINATELY would have changed the game.

: Sat May 23, 2009 5:14 pm  

rover49 wrote:

You keep going on about the Dixon incident, the player who decked Welham should have walked, which DEFINATELY would have changed the game.

So would the penalty try - Hull KR scored a few tackles after it.

: Sat May 23, 2009 5:29 pm  

xJAMIEx wrote:

Probably right? Theres no probably about it???
And as for the second I know for a fact I am right. It didnt happen all the game but towards the end when all the decisions were going your way your players were way too quick off the mark.
It got to the point were me and the cas fans around me were laughing in disbelief at some of the decisions. Never been on here to complain about a ref before but he never made it a fair game last night which was a real shame.

Exactly. The game was over by that time (if it happened) and there was no consequence from it. Btw, you did very well to spot all the offsides from behind the posts. Did you have panoramic binoculars?

: Sat May 23, 2009 5:44 pm  

These arguments are pointless, both sets of fans are going to believe that decisions by ref wrongly went against them.
It just sounds in this case as if we had a few major decisions go against us.

: Sat May 23, 2009 5:46 pm  

therobins wrote:

Exactly. The game was over by that time (if it happened) and there was no consequence from it. Btw, you did very well to spot all the offsides from behind the posts. Did you have panoramic binoculars?

Me and everyone around me noticed you players making no effort to get onside about 20 mins from the end so if the game was over by then you should have said then I would have gone on my way.
Just ask yourself where we were camped with and without the ball while this was going on. IIRC then I'd say quite near our own try line so rather than trying to be the funny zany poster why don't you think about it.

Bearded wrote:

These arguments are pointless, both sets of fans are going to believe that decisions by ref wrongly went against them.
It just sounds in this case as if we had a few major decisions go against us.

I just can't understand what game they were watching because the cas fans were going crazy were I was sat.

: Sat May 23, 2009 5:51 pm  

rover49 wrote:

You keep going on about the Dixon incident, the player who decked Welham should have walked, which DEFINATELY would have changed the game.

Welham slipped / ducked in to the tackle. A penalty - no more.

: Sat May 23, 2009 6:05 pm  

Nev0807 wrote:

Welham slipped / ducked in to the tackle. A penalty - no more.

Yeah ok then

: Sat May 23, 2009 6:12 pm  

Gaslight wrote:

So would the penalty try - Hull KR scored a few tackles after it.

Was that the were you got a penalty for a shove by Fox?
If it is I suggest you go and look up the rules which causes a penatly try to be awarded as that isn't what happened on friday night.