Re: 1or 2 New Players : Mon Jan 04, 2010 5:03 pm  

barnsley bill wrote:

It also mentions that it could be a loan signing that we make, i cant see Ryan Bailey getting much game time at Leeds, would we want him on loan?

Never, ever, ever, ever, most gutless, dirty forward in british rl.

Would rather have thackray than him.

Re: 1or 2 New Players : Mon Jan 04, 2010 5:23 pm  

I'd take Bailey because Cas need a cheap shot/bully type player, him and Frank Puletua would be perfect for this team because they're both rough, tough and aggressive in different ways and offer something different to Sarge/Huby/Jackson/Higgins who are all really similar sort of players.

Re: 1or 2 New Players : Mon Jan 04, 2010 5:39 pm  

We need a talented player who gives his all, not someone who puts in a cheap shot then hides behind someone else when he gets a reaction

Re: 1or 2 New Players : Mon Jan 04, 2010 5:45 pm  

Gaslight wrote:

I'd take Bailey because Cas need a cheap shot/bully type player, him and Frank Puletua would be perfect for this team because they're both rough, tough and aggressive in different ways and offer something different to Sarge/Huby/Jackson/Higgins who are all really similar sort of players.

We wont get puletua, after graham he saints best prop.

Bailey may be rough, but he certainly isnt tough or agressive (to players who can actually defend themselves anyway). Korki would offer us more go forward and courage than bailey!

Re: 1or 2 New Players : Mon Jan 04, 2010 5:58 pm  

pyeman wrote:

We wont get puletua, after graham he saints best prop.

Bailey may be rough, but he certainly isnt tough or agressive (to players who can actually defend themselves anyway). Korki would offer us more go forward and courage than bailey!

Tony Puletua is the 1 at St Helens, Frank Puletua is at Penrith Panthers.
Frank is Tony brother

Re: 1or 2 New Players : Mon Jan 04, 2010 5:59 pm  

madtigerman wrote:

Tony Puletua is the 1 at St Helens, Frank Puletua is at Penrith Panthers.
Frank is Tony brother

Ah i see my mistake, is he anywhere near as good as his brother?

Re: 1or 2 New Players : Mon Jan 04, 2010 6:04 pm  

pyeman wrote:

Ah i see my mistake, is he anywhere near as good as his brother?

No.

Re: 1or 2 New Players : Mon Jan 04, 2010 6:10 pm  

pyeman wrote:

Ah i see my mistake, is he anywhere near as good as his brother?

A few years ago he was far better, now he's gone down hill pretty quickly and not as good as Tony, but still more then solid.

Re: 1or 2 New Players : Mon Jan 04, 2010 7:41 pm  

barnsley bill wrote:

i cant see Ryan Bailey getting much game time at Leeds, would we want him on loan?

1:why can't you see him getting much game time at the Rhinos?
2:What do you class as not much game time?
3:why would we let him go out on loan?

Ryan Bailey is a 4 time GF winner who has played for the club since 2002,a period which has seen the Rhinos reap numerous trophies in the process.
Bailey has also played under the high calibre coaching staff like Tony Smith and Bluey McClennan,seems funny that they seem to like him and spectators that post on these forums don't!

Ryan will again get plenty of game time for the club next season, injuries permitting of course

Re: 1or 2 New Players : Mon Jan 04, 2010 7:53 pm  

madtigerman wrote:

Tony Puletua is the 1 at St Helens, Frank Puletua is at Penrith Panthers.
Frank is Tony brother

Nicely pointed out out mate,some folk never realise that brothers can play footy even when your club had both Kevin and Bob Beardmore!