: Mon Aug 17, 2009 2:23 pm  

arnt really gunna slag mcgoldrick of if its anybodys fault really its tm he moves him about every week and as a rugby player than can do your game no good remember we didnt sign him as a fullback all them years ago so if you put shenton at full back and he has a few bad games are we gunna get on at him maybe if he stays in the same posistion for the next 12 months works on his game and we see no improvement maybe some fans maybe right but otherwise get terry matterson to name his position and c if he keps him there to work and get his confidence back

my honest thoughts the guy aint a full back well others beg to differ

: Mon Aug 17, 2009 2:52 pm  

mac of cas wrote:

arnt really gunna slag mcgoldrick of if its anybodys fault really its tm he moves him about every week and as a rugby player than can do your game no good remember we didnt sign him as a fullback all them years ago so if you put shenton at full back and he has a few bad games are we gunna get on at him maybe if he stays in the same posistion for the next 12 months works on his game and we see no improvement maybe some fans maybe right but otherwise get terry matterson to name his position and c if he keps him there to work and get his confidence back

my honest thoughts the guy aint a full back well others beg to differ

What do you think his position is then?

: Mon Aug 17, 2009 4:57 pm  

mac of cas wrote:

arnt really gunna slag mcgoldrick of if its anybodys fault really its tm he moves him about every week and as a rugby player than can do your game no good remember we didnt sign him as a fullback all them years ago so if you put shenton at full back and he has a few bad games are we gunna get on at him maybe if he stays in the same posistion for the next 12 months works on his game and we see no improvement maybe some fans maybe right but otherwise get terry matterson to name his position and c if he keps him there to work and get his confidence back

my honest thoughts the guy aint a full back well others beg to differ

not arguing that point mate, we have seen him at fullback,Centre,standoff and loose and his performance is just the same no mater where you put him, so please tell me is his position none of these as there are not too many more places we can try him, i dont think it matters where you put him its his attitude that is the problem.

: Mon Aug 17, 2009 5:03 pm  

I think you will find when we signed him initially we signed him as a goal kicking centre.

Well I for one can count on 2 fingers the games he pas played in the position we signed him wigan away when we beat them 1st year back with manu etc and played very well and the widnes grand final and he has kicked 1 goal I think. There maybe a coupel of those but I reckon it is less than 5 times.

It is like buying carlos tevez and palying him in every position except the one you bought him to play in.

CRAZY!!!!!!

: Mon Aug 17, 2009 5:03 pm  

Do you know summat guys.
All we had to do in may when sherwin was injured, was get a loan scrum half in from NL1.

Then we could have left goldy at full back where he was playing very well and in a settled position.
Owen could have stayed on the wing, imo hes a winger not a FB.
Rangi chase at 6
New loan player at 7
Instead we struggled on playing players out of position, and imo ryan mcgoldrick is the one that as suffered the most.

Promote : Tue Aug 18, 2009 10:24 am  

poppys mum wrote:

Do you know summat guys.
All we had to do in may when sherwin was injured, was get a loan scrum half in from NL1.

All we had to do was pomote a kid - that is the only thing that irks me - if we had promoted an U21 and got beat then we at least gain something out of that in experience terms, but playing Widders as we did was in hindsight an error.

But hindsight is a wonderful thing, if Widders had spent the evening smashing Burrow, McGuire and Diskin every time he jumped out of dummy half - it would be TM for president and a masterstroke.

On balance though, it irks me we have played people out of position and upset the balanced side we had early on in the season, instead of bringing someone on.

: Tue Aug 18, 2009 11:26 am  

I say 'Yes' just so that I can find whom the boo-boys will target next

: Tue Aug 18, 2009 11:47 am  

poppys mum wrote:

Why dont the fans start singing his name again.
Give him a bit of confidence back.
Lets start on sunday against wigan.
If anyone as forgoten how the song goes its something like this.

DER DER DER DER RYAN MCGOLDRICK.

Agree 100%. Lets get behind the guy and give him that confidence back that he is lacking at the moment

: Tue Aug 18, 2009 12:56 pm  

ParanoidAndroid wrote:

I say 'Yes' just so that I can find whom the boo-boys will target next

its not a case of targeting anyone, my point all the way through this post is that he just does not seem to give a toss when he is out there and i dont think this attitude is anywhere near good enough from what is supposed to be one of our senior players, i am not as you call it a boo boy i just want to see some comitment and him earn his money.

: Tue Aug 18, 2009 1:43 pm  

tigerman10 wrote:

its not a case of targeting anyone, my point all the way through this post is that he just does not seem to give a toss when he is out there and i dont think this attitude is anywhere near good enough from what is supposed to be one of our senior players, i am not as you call it a boo boy i just want to see some comitment and him earn his money.

Give over, if Goldy went now, some other player (not any of the 'local' lads mind) would cop it if we lost. He is playing no better or no worse than the majority of the team but I don't see other threads with them getting lambasted?