Re: Carvell & Morley face potential bans : Thu Feb 18, 2010 3:02 pm  

citywolf wrote:

Correct. Outstanding.

Re: Carvell & Morley face potential bans : Thu Feb 18, 2010 3:24 pm  

Dead Man Walking wrote:

:lol:

Please feel free to expand on this if you are able to.

It's much better towards the discussion as opposed to using smiley faces only.

However, if your trying to insinuate that Morley has been a dirty player during his time at Warrington I think we both know you will be unable to justify that.

Re: Carvell & Morley face potential bans : Thu Feb 18, 2010 3:29 pm  

citywolf wrote:

if your trying to insinuate that Morley has been a dirty player during his time at Warrington I think we both know you will be unable to justify that.

Until saturday.

Re: Carvell & Morley face potential bans : Thu Feb 18, 2010 3:36 pm  

poppys mum wrote:

Until saturday.

Because he gave away a penalty?????? Hardly the mark of a consistent dirty player!

Re: Carvell & Morley face potential bans : Thu Feb 18, 2010 3:42 pm  

citywolf wrote:

Because he gave away a penalty?????? Hardly the mark of a consistent dirty player!

Well he's given away more this season than any other player, does that count?

Re: Carvell & Morley face potential bans : Thu Feb 18, 2010 3:49 pm  

Gazemous wrote:

Well he's given away more this season than any other player, does that count?

There are actually 6 players who have given away 5 penalties this season. Morley is one of them. Does this mean that all 6 of these players are vicious thugs?????

If you want to look at stats, Westerman gave away more penalties than Morley during 2009. Does this now rank young Joe up there with some of the dirtiest players in the game???

Re: Carvell & Morley face potential bans : Thu Feb 18, 2010 3:53 pm  

citywolf wrote:

There are actually 6 players who have given away 5 penalties this season. Morley is one of them. Does this mean that all 6 of these players are vicious thugs?????

If you want to look at stats, Westerman gave away more penalties than Morley during 2009. Does this now rank young Joe up there with some of the dirtiest players in the game???

Depends on the reason why the penalty as been given.
Laying on is trivial compared to a swinging arm.

I'll leave it to you to sift through reasons given for penalties.

Re: Carvell & Morley face potential bans : Thu Feb 18, 2010 4:12 pm  

I think it is fair to say Morley in a GB shirt is a hero, he is a tough, no nonsense british prop that has mellowed slightly as he as aged! the fact of the matter is he oftern is overcome by the red mist and allows his judgement to be swayed by his aggression. i have no real problem with the challenge saturday night, yes it was late, but reckles...IMO no!

there have been far worse, and i think we can all admit that.

i have no doubt if you were all to log onto castigers.com tomorrow and read that Adrian Morely had signed for us, whilst not liking his loiner herritage you would all be over the moon! i don't rememebr a game where morely has been bullied, i could name dozens where the entire cas pack have!!!

Re: Carvell & Morley face potential bans : Thu Feb 18, 2010 4:50 pm  

poppys mum wrote:

Depends on the reason why the penalty as been given.
Laying on is trivial compared to a swinging arm.

I'll leave it to you to sift through reasons given for penalties.

If you'd like to know the reasons for the penalties I'd suggest you do some research yourself.

My reason for mentioning Westerman was in order to draw an issue to the point you have made, in that unless you are aware of the reason for giving away penalties then the fact that Morley is joint top of the penalty chart is irrelevant.

I thank you for supporting my point, inadvertantly as I'm sure it was.

Re: Carvell & Morley face potential bans : Thu Feb 18, 2010 4:54 pm  

citywolf wrote:

If you'd like to know the reasons for the penalties I'd suggest you do some research yourself.

Cant be a**ed