: Mon Aug 24, 2009 11:31 am  

Drachen Feuer wrote:

You're a Cas fan, nobody expects you to be able to count past one.

: Mon Aug 24, 2009 11:41 am  

Sargent has received a formal caution

No other action taken

: Mon Aug 24, 2009 11:58 am  

casman2 wrote:

Sargent has received a formal caution

No other action taken

...and here endeth the thread

: Mon Aug 24, 2009 12:00 pm  

pyeman wrote:

It was an illegal challenge, i dont think anyone is arguing that (at least not after they have watched the replay), it was definatley late (but not dangerous or high) awarding a penalty was the correct call.

What's the problem with Tomkins then?

: Mon Aug 24, 2009 12:27 pm  

Did anyone listen to Tomkins interview after the game?

I recommend that you do.

He was articulate and quite funny in his comments on that tackle. No arrogance whatsoever, just a kid who loves playing Rugby League.

: Mon Aug 24, 2009 12:39 pm  

ABP' wrote:

What's the problem with Tomkins then?

if you look at my posts i have said he's a great player, i dont have a problem with him. If think he made more out of that challenge than there was ie as i said if the same challenge were on burrow or chase they would have bounced back up, but there are some that would call that gamesmanship.

Either way you look at its been dealt with now, a penatly was awarded (which iircc you scored from) and no further action is being taken.

: Mon Aug 24, 2009 12:44 pm  

chissitt wrote:

A bit late Tompkins had time to boil an egg before he was poleaxed. For someone what prides himself on sensible posts' I'm afraid this is not one of your better ones, I am being diplomatic put your post on the Wigin board and see the response.

had time to boil an egg, are you sure if you are to respond please atleast try to be accurate, or in your case in!!!! the best My Cousin Vinny's voice does your cooker defy the laws of physics....it was a late tackle a second at the least he is a profesional player and milked it for all its worth, job done, im sure most teams this season have had a player pull off an illegal tackle, even your lot.............

: Mon Aug 24, 2009 12:52 pm  

Rogues Gallery wrote:

Did anyone listen to Tomkins interview after the game?

I recommend that you do.

He was articulate and quite funny in his comments on that tackle. No arrogance whatsoever, just a kid who loves playing Rugby League.

He did also say Cas 'wasn't a very nice place to come to' aswell so that might not go down too well

: Mon Aug 24, 2009 12:52 pm  

pyeman wrote:

if you look at my posts i have said he's a great player, i dont have a problem with him. If think he made more out of that challenge than there was ie as i said if the same challenge were on burrow or chase they would have bounced back up, but there are some that would call that gamesmanship.

But Tomkins was injured, that's why he didn't ''bounce back up''.

pyeman wrote:

Either way you look at its been dealt with now, a penatly was awarded (which iircc you scored from) and no further action is being taken.

I agree, a caution is all it deserves but I thought it also warrented a Sin Bin during the game.

: Mon Aug 24, 2009 2:07 pm  

ABP' wrote:

But Tomkins was injured, that's why he didn't ''bounce back up''.



I agree, a caution is all it deserves but I thought it also warrented a Sin Bin during the game.

What injury did he sustain?