: Wed Dec 02, 2009 11:43 am  

Bonzo wrote:

I don't think you can argue with the effort he puts in though when given the chance. He may not be naturally gifted but he does work hard to earn his place in the team.

That goes for me to

: Wed Dec 02, 2009 11:48 am  

Bonzo wrote:

I don't think you can argue with the effort he puts in though when given the chance. He may not be naturally gifted but he does work hard to earn his place in the team.

Still not good enough thats how TM and the BOD see him thats why the club will allways be in the position its in.

: Wed Dec 02, 2009 11:49 am  

UrbanTiger wrote:

No, i honestly think that if he can hit some form will lead the line well - he is a big bloke and an oppurtunity and game time will do him the world of good.

There are championship props who i would prefer over him.

: Wed Dec 02, 2009 11:51 am  

Bonzo wrote:

I don't think you can argue with the effort he puts in though when given the chance. He may not be naturally gifted but he does work hard to earn his place in the team.

Agreed he does work harder and runs harder than most players in the team, but he doesnt score enough tries for a winger with only 5 last year and his defence can be suspect.

: Wed Dec 02, 2009 12:24 pm  

In an ideal world (if we could afford it!!), we could do with 3 positions covering IMO. A good strong prop so we dont see the defence weaken when Sarge has a breather, a good half back to cover for Shifty's inevitable injuries (I would like to see Brierley brought through), and a winger with pace (Wainy is a big favourite of mine due to his effort and workrate, as mentioned by others, but just not a SL standard winger - good squad player though). With this in mind, what are peoples thoughts on most important?? I know Speedy will say half back (or fecking half back depending on his mood!!!)

: Wed Dec 02, 2009 1:40 pm  

Laners wrote: Still not good enough thats how TM and the BOD see him thats why the club will allways be in the position its in. Are you sure you're not Tigerman1+1 signed into someone else's account? You certainly sound like him.

Laners wrote: Still not good enough thats how TM and the BOD see him thats why the club will allways be in the position its in. Are you sure you're not Tigerman1+1 signed into someone else's account? You certainly sound like him.

: Wed Dec 02, 2009 2:15 pm  

Bonzo wrote: Are you sure you're not Tigerman1+1 signed into someone else's account? You certainly sound like him. No and hope you are not one of the Cas fans that wood be happy seeing this player selected week in and week out.

Bonzo wrote: Are you sure you're not Tigerman1+1 signed into someone else's account? You certainly sound like him. No and hope you are not one of the Cas fans that wood be happy seeing this player selected week in and week out.

: Wed Dec 02, 2009 2:17 pm  

Certainly not....... i do not need to do that. bring the lad in can he be any worse than Ryan Boyle the home grown player that we have just got rid of another management masterstroke, but im sure you can see reason behind getting rid of a young prop local lad to bring in erm another prop of the same sort of level......come on Bonzo explain the TM reasoning behind this strange situation...

Laners ive learned that it is site suicide to show any form of criticism at all concerning TM. but ive never been a conformist and certainly not a sheep

: Wed Dec 02, 2009 2:39 pm  

tigerman1+1 wrote:

Certainly not....... i do not need to do that. bring the lad in can he be any worse than Ryan Boyle the home grown player that we have just got rid of another management masterstroke, but im sure you can see reason behind getting rid of a young prop local lad to bring in erm another prop of the same sort of level......come on Bonzo explain the TM reasoning behind this strange situation...

Ryan boyle who was offered another contract by the club and turned it down becuase he wanted to be a starting prop?

: Wed Dec 02, 2009 2:47 pm  

tigerman1+1 wrote:

Certainly not....... i do not need to do that. bring the lad in can he be any worse than Ryan Boyle the home grown player that we have just got rid of another management masterstroke, but im sure you can see reason behind getting rid of a young prop local lad to bring in erm another prop of the same sort of level......come on Bonzo explain the TM reasoning behind this strange situation...

Laners ive learned that it is site suicide to show any form of criticism at all concerning TM. but never been a conformist and certainly not a sheep

Good for you, and i say it as i see it i know the difference between what we should have and who are the weaknesses within the club and its not just on the playing field.