Re: ROBBED AGAIN : Sun Feb 28, 2010 11:20 am  

Roverswall wrote:

I belive for it to be a knock on it has to leave the players hand and travel forward and hit anyother object (other player, ground, post pad etc) but if the ball is regathered by the same player before it hits another object then its playon.
So in this situation the only question in the VR's mind was did the player have control of the grounding.

Indeed, and that's what he got completely and utterly wrong. There's absolutely zero doubt that that try shouldn't have stood.

Re: ROBBED AGAIN : Sun Feb 28, 2010 11:29 am  

itsalldarntlane wrote:

my god lad, you just cant handle the truth
CAS WERE ROBBED
but it suits soopa doopa league so nothing will be said about the two clowns, oops officials

The truth is that Rovers won, that's a fact, it's you that struggles with the truth, and as for it suiting the RFL that Rovers won last night, well that would be a first.

Re: ROBBED AGAIN : Sun Feb 28, 2010 11:34 am  

as a Hull fc fan i hate to say it but i do n't think you were robbed?
your team just threw it away with their lack of control inside the rovers half
the game could have been won in the first half if they'd taken half their chances.

Re: ROBBED AGAIN : Sun Feb 28, 2010 11:42 am  

I was at the game and could see the video decision on the big screen and i thought it was a knock-on.

CHURCHILL does have a point though, the records and league table will show that we lost and we can't change that fact.

Re: ROBBED AGAIN : Sun Feb 28, 2010 11:53 am  

CHURCHILL wrote:

The truth is that Rovers won, that's a fact, it's you that struggles with the truth, and as for it suiting the RFL that Rovers won last night, well that would be a first.

we know the result numpty but almost all the rugby league world knows that game was given to rovers by two incompetant fools who obviously dont understand the rules of the game.

youre not related to ganson are you ? the similarities point that way

bye bye little lad

Re: ROBBED AGAIN : Sun Feb 28, 2010 12:06 pm  

itsalldarntlane wrote:

we know the result numpty but almost all the rugby league world knows that game was given to rovers by two incompetant fools who obviously dont understand the rules of the game.

youre not related to ganson are you ? the similarities point that way

bye bye little lad

The same incompetant fools who missed forward passes for two of your trys. Swings and roundabouts. fwiw i said to our lass we were very lucky try was given but so were you on the forward passes

Re: ROBBED AGAIN : Sun Feb 28, 2010 12:17 pm  

itsalldarntlane wrote:

we know the result numpty but almost all the rugby league world knows that game was given to rovers by two incompetant fools who obviously dont understand the rules of the game.

youre not related to ganson are you ? the similarities point that way

bye bye little lad

As mentioned elsewhere, Cas had their fair share of 50/50 calls go their way, result stands, off you pop, toodle pip.

Re: ROBBED AGAIN : Sun Feb 28, 2010 1:05 pm  

CHURCHILL wrote:

As mentioned elsewhere, Cas had their fair share of 50/50 calls go their way, result stands, off you pop, toodle pip.

50/50 calls my armpit

your comments show you havent seen the game like the fella before you

my fault for replying to a no mark troll

bet ya not even from the fish market too

Re: ROBBED AGAIN : Sun Feb 28, 2010 1:06 pm  

Gaslight wrote:

But 3 KR trys came from: Offside, obstruction & incorrect play the ball and a knock on (the actual try AND in the build up.

Yet never in the history of Castleford has the boot been on the other foot, take it like a man.

Wakefield lost to Saints by two tries that would almost certainly have been wiped by the Video Ref on a Sky game. So what, it's tough on us but there is no guarantee that we would have won over the 80 mins.

Saints won and nothing will change that, I'm sure over the season things will even themselves out. When that happens to Cas I do hope you will be as vociferous in your attack on the Ref and show your utmost support for the club you and the Ref robbed.

All Refs are rubbish when you lose especially tight games, have you not sussed that yet.

Re: ROBBED AGAIN : Sun Feb 28, 2010 1:08 pm  

CHURCHILL wrote:

The truth is that Rovers won, that's a fact, it's you that struggles with the truth, and as for it suiting the RFL that Rovers won last night, well that would be a first.

Rovers won because of a bad decision simple as.
You have the 2 points we dont. It's history now.