Re: The last 2 times : Thu Apr 09, 2009 12:34 pm  

El Diablo wrote:

His first comment was technically accurate (if meaningless) though was it not?

No, not technically accurate. What he said was:

Snake Eater wrote:

The last 2 times saints have knocked leeds out of the CC, leeds have won the title.

He said this after Leeds' defeat to St Helens on Sunday which the last time I checked was in 2009. So unless he already knows the outcome of the 2009 GF in October it's an inaccurate statement, to me.

If he'd have said it before Sunday's defeat then he would have been OK.

Re: The last 2 times : Thu Apr 09, 2009 2:39 pm  

tvoc wrote:

No, not technically accurate. What he said was:



He said this after Leeds' defeat to St Helens on Sunday which the last time I checked was in 2009. So unless he already knows the outcome of the 2009 GF in October it's an inaccurate statement, to me.

If he'd have said it before Sunday's defeat then he would have been OK.

A fair point and well made.

Your honour, I withdraw my remark.