Re: Leeds Player of the Year so far... : Wed May 18, 2016 4:59 pm  

Keinhorst has been player of the year, and that says it all. He's an eighteenth man type player who wouldn't get into our team if it was fit and/or firing yet he's been our best. That's how bad the rest have been.

Re: Leeds Player of the Year so far... : Wed May 18, 2016 5:11 pm  

craigizzard wrote:

Keinhorst has been player of the year, and that says it all. He's an eighteenth man type player who wouldn't get into our team if it was fit and/or firing yet he's been our best. That's how bad the rest have been.

Your talking rubbish mate, Jimmy K is as good as someone like Atkins or Sarginson, its just that becasue he plays for us he cant get a game in the centres. Defensively solid and decent in attack, just not as skillful as Moon or as big a threat as Watkins (real Watkins not the impostor currently playing for us)

Having said that, Burrow has probably been our best player when played at 9

Re: Leeds Player of the Year so far... : Wed May 18, 2016 5:18 pm  

Jimmy the German hands down.

Re: Leeds Player of the Year so far... : Wed May 18, 2016 5:22 pm  

leedsnsouths wrote:

Your talking rubbish mate, Jimmy K is as good as someone like Atkins or Sarginson, its just that becasue he plays for us he cant get a game in the centres. Defensively solid and decent in attack, just not as skillful as Moon or as big a threat as Watkins (real Watkins not the impostor currently playing for us)

Having said that, Burrow has probably been our best player when played at 9

So what part of "he wouldn't get in our team if everyone was fit and firing" is "absolute rubbish" when you yourself admit he wouldn't play ahead of Watkins or Moon? Which on-form second row are you picking Keinhorst ahead of, Ferres, Ablett or Ward?

I'm not knocking Keinhorst, he's got a great work ethic and makes the very most of average ability, but if he's been our best (and he has) then it's little bloody wonder we're at the bottom of the league.

Re: Leeds Player of the Year so far... : Wed May 18, 2016 5:39 pm  

craigizzard wrote:

So what part of "he wouldn't get in our team if everyone was fit and firing" is "absolute rubbish" when you yourself admit he wouldn't play ahead of Watkins or Moon? Which on-form second row are you picking Keinhorst ahead of, Ferres, Ablett or Ward?

I'm not knocking Keinhorst, he's got a great work ethic and makes the very most of average ability, but if he's been our best (and he has) then it's little bloody wonder we're at the bottom of the league.

Keinhorst is more 'on form' than anyone you've mentioned, so in my eyes he deserves to keep his place in the starting 13.

Re: Leeds Player of the Year so far... : Wed May 18, 2016 6:02 pm  

Jimmy by plenty & imo a definate 1st 17 with everybody fit.
Lilley & Handley have also impressed imo in p1$$ poor team performances.

Re: Leeds Player of the Year so far... : Wed May 18, 2016 6:19 pm  

William Eve wrote:

I'm firmly in the TVOC camp.

No surprise

Re: Leeds Player of the Year so far... : Wed May 18, 2016 6:42 pm  

william has been as mischievous as ever with his poll options in naming ward and some other none option out of a possible 6 choices:roll:

i've voted for jimmy as he has really given 100% every time he has stepped onto the field unlike certain soft cock's i could mention that simply don't deserve to wear the shirt

noteable mentions go to these players:
i don't think that galloway has been as bad as people have made out
ferres has always had a good dig and would have been a revelation in last seasons side,so theres still plenty to come from him imo
jjb has certainly lifted us since his return,but he needs to defend 1 in from the ruck and not out wide,although this was not his choice and he merely put his hand up for duty when selected to defend out in the centre position
garbutt has started to give us some grunt up front
lilley has looked very promising in a very ordinary side on numerous occasions
handley has been pretty good tbh and if hall and briscoe were both fit to return this weekend then it would be a toss up between them on who missed out at handley's expense

Re: Leeds Player of the Year so far... : Thu May 19, 2016 9:07 am  

Galloway has been good.

Leeds could have Webcke, Tallis and Steve Price - but with the go forward we have atm, they would look equally as bland.

Re: Leeds Player of the Year so far... : Thu May 19, 2016 10:11 am  

krisleeds wrote:

Galloway has been good.

Leeds could have Webcke, Tallis and Steve Price - but with the go forward we have atm, they would look equally as bland.

Jimmy has been one of our better players this year and if everyone fit he should still make the 17 useful bench option to have.

Galloway was poor early season, granted he is getting better every week.

Don't get the last point if Leeds had webcke, Price and tallis they would provide the go forward.