Re: Match Officials : Fri Apr 10, 2009 9:14 pm  

Dicko_09 wrote:

Can someone remind me there use?
These are my views
1.the video ref tonight was either stupid or blind
Webb was played onside by Burrow and did not start a forward run until Burrow had passed him
McGuires try was a try the ball went backwards
Sheriffes try was obstructed, there was a possibility of Buchanon tackling the kicker
2. the ref was just poor
Ablett was sent off even though the 'ref' had not called held, is Ablett meant to know if there is no call
one on one rip by sinfield, newtons arm didn't touch the ground so you can still rip it
3. touch judges i am not even going to waste time on them, waste of space just for a change

FFS... are you clueless?

Webb was offside from the play of the ball and started to move forward before Burrow passed him. Either way Hemmings read the rule out in commentry. Correct decision.

McGuires try: The ball was knocked forward by the hand of JJB and McGuire received the ball in front of first contact.

Ablett was sin binned for being a pillock. The momentum of the player had stopped and he pushed him again not once, but twice. He deserved it.

JJB would have still been about 3 or 4 meters from Jefferies as the kick was put in.

With the Sinfield incident he had already dropped on Newton before he ripped the ball. Yes, it was 50/50 but not wrong.

TJ's - did they get anything wrong? I cant remember. Oh yes, Leeds 1st try.


Nuff said!

PWNED

Re: Match Officials : Fri Apr 10, 2009 9:14 pm  

Dicko_09 wrote:

right but he didnt start to move forward until the player with the ball (burrow) passed him

that doesn't matter, he could be on the moon, but he was offside.

: Fri Apr 10, 2009 9:14 pm  

You sure you're a ref?

Read the "retire at the play the ball" section of the rules, then read how you can't be played onside in the normal fashion in this circumstance.

Then quit referreeing because you obviously don't know the rules.

Re: The most disgusting referee exhibition ever : Fri Apr 10, 2009 9:15 pm  

the wicker man wrote:

Does that mean you could have 10 players stood in a similar position that webb was in along the defending teams line??

In his refereeing handbook it would appear to be the case.

: Fri Apr 10, 2009 9:15 pm  

chris joynt was a master at it!!!!!!!!!!
it happens half a dozen times every game. it was a joke decision

: Fri Apr 10, 2009 9:15 pm  

FearTheVee wrote:

You sure you're a ref?

Read the "retire at the play the ball" section of the rules, then read how you can't be played onside in the normal fashion in this circumstance.

Then quit referreeing because you obviously don't know the rules.

: Fri Apr 10, 2009 9:16 pm  

tad rhino wrote:

it happens half a dozen times every game. it was a joke decision

Does it?

Can you give any examples of occasions when you've seen it happen?

: Fri Apr 10, 2009 9:16 pm  

happened in the hull derby and last night. happens every game. might be technically correct but it never ever gets pulled up on.

: Fri Apr 10, 2009 9:16 pm  

If the ref had been completely on the ball you wouldn't have scored a point tonight.

Re: Match Officials : Fri Apr 10, 2009 9:17 pm  

Marto wrote:

that doesn't matter, he could be on the moon, but he was offside.

Ellery Hanley scored most of his tries from similar positions and not just for Leeds.