Re: IN 2024 | Brodie Croft - Expires: 2026 : Thu Oct 19, 2023 7:12 pm  

chapylad wrote:

Intrigued how much the likes of Shaun Johnson is on or for that matter Mikey Lewis.
And if we offered £250k plus £200k wages to Mikey Lewis could we have got him instead?
Don`t get me wrong I`m happy with Croft but it`s a hell of a lot of money both in transfer fee and salary.
A CC and a GF win would pay back the investment for sure.

Top echelon halves like Johnson, Cleary etc are on twice that. Personally I don't think Lewis is anywhere near the player Croft is at present. In my opinion we've got the right man and shouldn't get too hung up on the wages.

Re: IN 2024 | Brodie Croft - Expires: 2026 : Thu Oct 19, 2023 7:25 pm  

Croft is definitely better than Lewis.

Re: IN 2024 | Brodie Croft - Expires: 2026 : Thu Oct 19, 2023 10:59 pm  

Croft may go back to the NRL. If after 2 years I could live with that. Having said that, if you look at what NRL clubs are after, I'd guess its halfbacks that are organisers/kickers. Its no coincidence that the top two in this regard made the GF. It also explains why - to us bizarrely - Wests wanted Sezer. Croft isn't that kind of halfback, and when he was asked to play that role at the Broncos he folded. Clubs will also remember that, and even if he does go back to the NRL it wouldn't be as a superstar, it would be similar to Cogger.

Re: IN 2024 | Brodie Croft - Expires: 2026 : Fri Oct 20, 2023 12:45 am  

Is Lewis even that good? He looks more of a Luke Robinson level half, than a Danny McGuire level half.

[Ex-Swarcliffe Rhino]

Re: IN 2024 | Brodie Croft - Expires: 2026 : Fri Oct 20, 2023 11:59 am  

Jack Burton wrote:

Is Lewis even that good? He looks more of a Luke Robinson level half, than a Danny McGuire level half.

I like Lewis and think he has the potential to go far but DM is/was different gravy.
Lewis will have to go some to have half the career Maggsy did.

Re: IN 2024 | Brodie Croft - Expires: 2026 : Fri Oct 20, 2023 6:27 pm  

McGuire was insane. You see it more as time passes. His ability to read the game was unrivalled.

Re: IN 2024 | Brodie Croft - Expires: 2026 : Fri Oct 20, 2023 6:42 pm  

Jack Burton wrote:

Is Lewis even that good? He looks more of a Luke Robinson level half, than a Danny McGuire level half.

I quite like Lewis as he`s a niggly little get and has the x factor to turn a game.
His defence isn`t brilliant and needs working on and I agree he is not as good as Croft.
I`m amazed at the amount we are paying Croft and hope it doesn`t affect the dressing room.
I suppose if we are winning nobody will care.

Re: IN 2024 | Brodie Croft - Expires: 2026 : Fri Oct 20, 2023 6:57 pm  

I’ll stick my neck out and say we’ll get better value for money from Croft than from Tetevano or some other high-profile signings…

Re: IN 2024 | Brodie Croft - Expires: 2026 : Sat Oct 21, 2023 9:05 am  

At last sanity prevails, we have signed a tried and tested player. Obviously paid a large sum of money, in the current super league climate there isn’t much talent about so top players command a premium. I also like some of the other signings, if Smith can’t bring about a top four spot with the strengthened squad something will be radically wrong. Hopefully some of the younger members of the squad will blossom in the new season.

Re: IN 2024 | Brodie Croft - Expires: 2026 : Sun Oct 22, 2023 7:28 pm  

Jack Burton wrote:

Is Lewis even that good? He looks more of a Luke Robinson level half, than a Danny McGuire level half.

Lewis looked good today JB and if as everyone is saying that Croft is better, then we have got one hell of a player.
I personally would have preferred Lewis on much less money, less of a transfer fee and wouldn`t have taken an overseas spot.
I must admit that I have not seen much of Croft but have seen a dozen or so games with Lewis playing.