Re: New signing- Weller Hauraki : Fri Nov 19, 2010 2:56 pm  

sgtwilko wrote:

why arnt you using any of them? to be honest lima is rocks or diamonds, finch is a ham and eggs NRL half back good but not spectacular. not good enough the make the origin shirt his own. hoffman is as good as any backrower in the world so fair do's on that signing. but a new contract for carmont? with phelps roberts, richards, tommy,finch? cant you produce any backs?

Phelps has left. As for producing backs Sam Tomkins and Goulding both featured for England and we have Stefan Marsh and Josh Charnley pushing for the first team but at the minute young and still much to prove but will get game time this season. Ainscough another we produced but deemed surpless to requirements and with the lack of interest in his signing seems was the right decision. Bradford hardly had to fight anyone for his signiture apart from Widnes.

Re: New signing- Weller Hauraki : Fri Nov 19, 2010 2:58 pm  

McDermott's first signing is an average back-rower.

I'm shocked.

Re: New signing- Weller Hauraki : Fri Nov 19, 2010 3:23 pm  

Sky Sports Website has Hauraki as only missing the Opening game of the season last year.

That's a good sign.

That also means that playing against Leeds he has a 100%, played 1, won 1 record. (Eat your heart out TVOC!)

Re: New signing- Weller Hauraki : Fri Nov 19, 2010 3:29 pm  

Bill_Barlow wrote:

Phelps has left. As for producing backs Sam Tomkins and Goulding both featured for England and we have Stefan Marsh and Josh Charnley pushing for the first team but at the minute young and still much to prove but will get game time this season. Ainscough another we produced but deemed surpless to requirements and with the lack of interest in his signing seems was the right decision. Bradford hardly had to fight anyone for his signiture apart from Widnes.

That was my point! RG was been mischievous on here having a go about leeds overseas signings and our academy. If you check my earlier post i mentioned marsh and charnely so why keep carmont? Of course Tomkins is a belter, I don't rate goulding but can see he had a good season. rouges was hinting at Leeds academy not producing. Wigan have a great academy but still have 5 overseas backs and have resigned deacon Who will be 32 at the start of the season. your starting halfbacks finch/deacon will have a combined age of 62? Not great for a team boasting the best academy around is it? My point is rogues was having a troll, it was pretty weak as his own club can be picked at quite easy. you can spin the academy/overseas thing many ways.

Re: New signing- Weller Hauraki : Fri Nov 19, 2010 3:52 pm  

Brett Finch is 29, and has played S.O.O.
Deacon played about 50% of the games last season, and will more than likely do the same again next year.

Wigan team was younger than Leeds last season, and will be again in 2011
Carmonts extra year was automatically triggered by the number of games he played in 2010.

Wigan have seven players in the England U18 academy squad to face Australia in a couple of weeks time, how many are there from Leeds?

Re: New signing- Weller Hauraki : Fri Nov 19, 2010 4:04 pm  

Rogues Gallery wrote:

Brett Finch is 29, and has played S.O.O.
Deacon played about 50% of the games last season, and will more than likely do the same again next year.

Wigan team was younger than Leeds last season, and will be again in 2011
Carmonts extra year was automatically triggered by the number of games he played in 2010.

Wigan have seven players in the England U18 academy squad to face Australia in a couple of weeks time, how many are there from Leeds?

Yeah. You were best Supported Club, League Leaders, Floodlit 9's Champs, Man of Steel, Young Player, Under 20's winners, Club of the Year, Coach of the Year, Most Points Scored, Least Points Conceded, Leading Try Scorer. The lot!

By far the superior team last year.

The thing is though mate, as of right now, all that counts for nothing, and come February 12th, 14 teams will line up to start all over again, and for that brief moment before kick off... all will be equal.

14 Teams level on points
14 Teams level on tries scored
14 Clubs with potential Men of Steel
14 Club of the Year Candidates
14 Coach of the Year Candidates
14 Grand Final Contenders...
... and 1 Pink Shirt.

Re: New signing- Weller Hauraki : Fri Nov 19, 2010 4:08 pm  

Rogues Gallery wrote:

Brett Finch is 29, and has played S.O.O.
Deacon played about 50% of the games last season, and will more than likely do the same again next year.

Wigan team was younger than Leeds last season, and will be again in 2011
Carmonts extra year was automatically triggered by the number of games he played in 2010.

Wigan have seven players in the England U18 academy squad to face Australia in a couple of weeks time, how many are there from Leeds?

Lets hope they perform better than their all conquering 1st team counter-parts on the international stage.
We have 1 in u18 squad and would of had 2 but for injury of course you knew that though and are once again giving it large about the pie acadamy that has been long overshadowed in terms of producing quality 1st team players by our very own.
This year we have..
Mcguire.
Bishop.
Jjb.
Ablett.
Burrow.
Hall.
Mcshane.
Burgess.
Clarkson.
Smith.
Hood.
Singleton.
Stewart.
Casey.
Sinfield.
Watkins.
All of which are acadamy produced and as you know many have proved their quality so although we are carrying a few more over-seas players than usual we still have enough of our "Own" within the squad and there's still more to come.

Re: New signing- Weller Hauraki : Fri Nov 19, 2010 4:17 pm  

welcome weller

Re: New signing- Weller Hauraki : Fri Nov 19, 2010 4:19 pm  

RG is correct IMV in bemoaning the fact that currently we don't appear to have players coming through the academy to prevent the need for us to recruit from outside.
Only having 1 representative in the international academy squad isn't good enough for a club our size.
Something that many on here have also bemoaned.
His point would have much more weight if his own club had built on the success of their academy by only promoting from within.
Sadly that shows up the gulf between the academy & SL.

Re: New signing- Weller Hauraki : Fri Nov 19, 2010 4:19 pm  

Rogues Gallery wrote:

Brett Finch is 29, and has played S.O.O.
Deacon played about 50% of the games last season, and will more than likely do the same again next year.

Wigan team was younger than Leeds last season, and will be again in 2011
Carmonts extra year was automatically triggered by the number of games he played in 2010.

Wigan have seven players in the England U18 academy squad to face Australia in a couple of weeks time, how many are there from Leeds?

Brett finch is 30 in august. Brett finch was not the answer to the nsw half back problem he was never good enough to make the shirt his own. Many other good halfbacks failed to do that too. As I said he is a good ham n eggs nrl half. He's no world beater but will do a job. without deacon who will be 32 Come season start you looked Vulnerable. so for all those great academy kids playing for England you have 30 year old Aussie and a 32 year old deacon arguably as your preferred starting halves? And 5 imports in your back line? an import kicking your goals? If your honest mate that's not great is it? you can have great kids but still not produce the ones to do the job. Leeds despite having some issues with it's academy keeps offering up good players we just brought through another batch this season and signed the likes of hardaker. Leeds have enough good kids coming through. There is no need to hit the panic button.

I think Leeds have 1 player in the 18's squad. At 18's Paul rideout was regarded as the best footballer in the world. True story.