Re: Sutcliffe and Minns secure long term deals. : Tue Jul 09, 2013 9:59 am  

Why not move sinfield to hooker ?

Re: Sutcliffe and Minns secure long term deals. : Tue Jul 09, 2013 12:27 pm  

Takes Sinfield too far away from areas where he's going to be able to do most damage with his passing and kicking game.

He's also not got the acceleration you need to play dummy half in the modern era and exploit slow or lazy markers.

Re: Sutcliffe and Minns secure long term deals. : Tue Jul 09, 2013 12:37 pm  

Andy Gilder wrote:

He's also not got the acceleration you need to play dummy half in the modern era and exploit slow or lazy markers.

Thought you were talking about Sinfield, not McShane.

Re: Sutcliffe and Minns secure long term deals. : Tue Jul 09, 2013 1:17 pm  

Gotcha wrote:

Pinning all future tie down of the stand off role on Sutcliffe, may end up not been fulfilled.

Gibbersh. Just gibberish.

Not taking an issue with whatever point you're attempting to make. I can overlook typos. I don't even bring up the been and being issue any more. However that sentence is just authentic frontier gibberish.

Re: Sutcliffe and Minns secure long term deals. : Tue Jul 09, 2013 4:33 pm  

G1 wrote:

Gibbersh. Just gibberish.

Not taking an issue with whatever point you're attempting to make. I can overlook typos. I don't even bring up the been and being issue any more. However that sentence is just authentic frontier gibberish.

Blazing Saddles. Question, does Gotcha live in a town where everyone is related and have the same surname? Hang on a minute, that would be Cas!

Re: Sutcliffe and Minns secure long term deals. : Tue Jul 09, 2013 4:38 pm  

Going back to the topic, Sutcliffe has made the first steps and needs to continue his devlopment. He isn't going to do that being played out of position. Although, I accept the point that, to some extent, the positions in question are interchangeable.
One thing I did notice on Friday was that he wasn't averse to the odd cheap shot in the tackle. If he continues with that and develops further, he'll be about as popular as Bailey by this time next year.

Re: Sutcliffe and Minns secure long term deals. : Wed Jul 10, 2013 8:12 am  

I actually think that playing him out of position is a good move. Get him ready for the physicallity of SL, without giving him the burden of being chief playmaker. He needs to get used to being hit by big blokes, and needs to get used to the speed of play before he can start to direct it

Re: Sutcliffe and Minns secure long term deals. : Wed Jul 10, 2013 2:39 pm  

That is one argument, the potential for unnecessary injury through over work at a young age is another. In fairness, I aren't too fussed as long as he keeps getting a game because, he has demonstrated he is worthy of a place.

Re: Sutcliffe and Minns secure long term deals. : Wed Jul 10, 2013 11:31 pm  

The Eagle wrote:

I actually think that playing him out of position is a good move. Get him ready for the physicallity of SL, without giving him the burden of being chief playmaker. He needs to get used to being hit by big blokes, and needs to get used to the speed of play before he can start to direct it

I would agree.Any game time he gets from now on is a bonus as i guess he has already had as much or more than he or the club would have anticipated at the start of the year.

Re: Sutcliffe and Minns secure long term deals. : Thu Jul 11, 2013 3:09 am  

Lawrie L wrote:

I love it, A Hunslet mug slating one of our players

Don't worry, Joe Vickery is still ready for you

he's just annoyed that jimmy watson (presumably his son from his posts) didn't get a chance with Leeds.

as for vickery i hear he's been offered 4/5 times, Hunslet have turned him down every time.