Re: 2017 | Out of Contract Players : Tue May 02, 2017 8:09 pm  

Gotcha I've noticed before you don't rate Harvey Spence and your more than entitled to your opinions, but he has represented England, and also been a regular part of a very good unbeaten u16s side, to claim his possible deal with the Rhinos is an inside job seems harsh. Remember these are young lads who are trying to get their foot in the door at the same time as the pressure of Gcses or whatever they are called now.

Re: 2017 | Out of Contract Players : Tue May 02, 2017 8:14 pm  

Dadsylad wrote:

Gotcha I've noticed before you don't rate Harvey Spence and your more than entitled to your opinions, but he has represented England, and also been a regular part of a very good unbeaten u16s side, to claim his possible deal with the Rhinos is an inside job seems harsh. Remember these are young lads who are trying to get their foot in the door at the same time as the pressure of Gcses or whatever they are called now.

Who said I didn't rate him? And I never said anything about an inside job. I however don't think he is as good as a lot of players and has got where he as through people he knows, which others don't get that chance. That doesn't mean I don't rate him, just I think there is better.

Re: 2017 | Out of Contract Players : Tue May 02, 2017 8:27 pm  

It's just that you don't think he'll become a first team player so for me it's the same thing. As I say your opinion is as valid as anyone's and maybe inside job was the wrong phrase. I just think all these lads should be positively encouraged not accused of cronyism.

Re: 2017 | Out of Contract Players : Tue May 02, 2017 8:54 pm  

Dadsylad wrote:

It's just that you don't think he'll become a first team player so for me it's the same thing. As I say your opinion is as valid as anyone's and maybe inside job was the wrong phrase. I just think all these lads should be positively encouraged not accused of cronyism.

There is a lot of players who get opportunities that others don't due to who they know. That is not reserved for Spence, whom happens to be much better than others who get by with contacts. However, I still don't think he would have got as far without it. Good luck to him though, if he kicks on from it.

I remember him at under 12/13 and although my memory is not great, I think he might have been a fullback then. He was very good in that age group. But when I look at people with contacts, I also look a the scrum half whom I have also mentioned previously, Scrimshaw. He was in the best junior team in the game, but he wasn't that good really. Leeds chose him over a super half who was at East Leeds and ended up going to Bradford instead, and that was done because of contacts and bait to catch something else.

Re: 2017 | Out of Contract Players : Thu May 04, 2017 8:35 am  

Gotcha wrote:

Leeds chose him over a super half who was at East Leeds and ended up going to Bradford instead, and that was done because of contacts and bait to catch something else.

Who is the half who went to Bradford mate ?

Re: 2017 | Out of Contract Players : Thu May 04, 2017 9:02 am  

Gotcha wrote:

Been offered deals, not yet able to sign, I don't think.

Spence is typical of someone getting a deal based on contacts.

The kid has earned it he's come on in spades since playing regurlarly at this level & his England selection shows that imo.

Re: 2017 | Out of Contract Players : Thu May 04, 2017 9:20 am  

The Eclipse wrote:

Who is the half who went to Bradford mate ?

I can't remember his full name, so might be guessing a bit, but I believe he has just been offered a contract for their under 19's. Think it is Luke Littlewood, or something very similar to that. Was at East Leeds, and was miles better than Scrimshaw.

Re: 2017 | Out of Contract Players : Thu May 04, 2017 9:35 am  

Gotcha wrote:

I can't remember his full name, so might be guessing a bit, but I believe he has just been offered a contract for their under 19's. Think it is Luke Littlewood, or something very similar to that. Was at East Leeds, and was miles better than Scrimshaw.

i player open age at Lock lane and we had a cracking under 18 side, there were some superb players in that side 4-5 looked destined to be excellent pro players and 1-2 of them did have some pro club time, but a skinny slightly spotty kid who had had guts and a good engine ended but who was not one of the star players ended up being picked up by wakey and ended up being a super star, Gareth Ellis.

you cant judge who is good at 13-15-17, they aren't always the ones who make it.

Re: 2017 | Out of Contract Players : Thu May 04, 2017 9:39 am  

rollin thunder wrote:

i player open age at Lock lane and we had a cracking under 18 side, there were some superb players in that side 4-5 looked destined to be excellent pro players and 1-2 of them did have some pro club time, but a skinny slightly spotty kid who had had guts and a good engine ended but who was not one of the star players ended up being picked up by wakey and ended up being a super star, Gareth Ellis.

you cant judge who is good at 13-15-17, they aren't always the ones who make it.

I think you are missing the point that was made above mate. And if you had been posting on here long enough, you certainly wouldn't need to preach to me about Gareth Ellis going to Wakefield, and he was more than a skinny spotty kid.

Re: 2017 | Out of Contract Players : Thu May 04, 2017 11:59 am  

Gotcha re Spence he's always played so. The lad at fb for stanningley was lucas pearson who was possibly the quickest kid I've ever seen.