: Tue May 12, 2009 12:45 pm  

rhinoms wrote:

Does that mean you'll end up with robinson??

That was the rumour, money plus Robinson.

Really hope we can keep hold of Broughy, he is a fantastic player on his day.

: Tue May 12, 2009 12:47 pm  

adam9641 wrote:

That was the rumour, money plus Robinson.

Really hope we can keep hold of Broughy, he is a fantastic player on his day.

Only thing I'd say is he's had quite a few clubs for someone of his age. I don't doubt his talent, on his day he's a very good player, but I get the impression there's other factors at work.

: Tue May 12, 2009 12:47 pm  

adam9641 wrote:

That was the rumour, money plus Robinson.

Really hope we can keep hold of Broughy, he is a fantastic player on his day.

TBH i think he'd be better staying at wakey at least till the end of the season,JK seems to be building a decent squad and imo the giant's are no "step up" from where he is.

: Tue May 12, 2009 12:55 pm  

rhinoms wrote:

TBH i think he'd be better staying at wakey at least till the end of the season,JK seems to be building a decent squad and imo the giant's are no "step up" from where he is.

Agreed.

Jk really rates Broughy too so it would be strange for JK to give the move the go ahead unless there is more to it. But I don't go with the Broughy disrupts the team etc prob just his reputation but he seems to half calmed down a lot this season

: Tue May 12, 2009 12:56 pm  

Lord_Percy wrote:

Only thing I'd say is he's had quite a few clubs for someone of his age. I don't doubt his talent, on his day he's a very good player, but I get the impression there's other factors at work.

Yeah, last season I saw him give an interview to sky after one of games he had a right dig at the players saying they were not good enough or something along those lines.

: Tue May 12, 2009 12:58 pm  

adam9641 wrote:

Agreed.

Jk really rates Broughy too so it would be strange for JK to give the move the go ahead unless there is more to it. But I don't go with the Broughy disrupts the team etc prob just his reputation but he seems to half calmed down a lot this season

From an outside point of view there did seem to be teething problems last year with him and drew re-who the "chief" was!!
If that's sorted and you keep him with drew and obst they'll cause many teams problems.

: Tue May 12, 2009 1:01 pm  

rhinoms wrote:

From an outside point of view there did seem to be teething problems last year with him and drew re-who the "chief" was!!
If that's sorted and you keep him with drew and obst they'll cause many teams problems.

Yeah last season that is where our season went down the pan. They both like to run the show and take charge so they clashed.

They seemed to have sorted it out this season. If I had to chose one of them though it would be Broughy as Drew is coming to the end of his career and I believe Drews contract runs out at the end of the season

[Ex-Swarcliffe Rhino]

: Tue May 12, 2009 1:04 pm  

adam9641 wrote:

Agreed.

Jk really rates Broughy too so it would be strange for JK to give the move the go ahead unless there is more to it. But I don't go with the Broughy disrupts the team etc prob just his reputation but he seems to half calmed down a lot this season

TBH Brough has played some of his best rugby under Kear and its no suprise that he is doing it under him again. Strange player Brough, deffo splits the RL public.

: Tue May 12, 2009 2:28 pm  

rhinoms wrote:

TBH i think he'd be better staying at wakey at least till the end of the season,JK seems to be building a decent squad and imo the giant's are no "step up" from where he is.

The league table and who is in and out of the Challenge Cup would suggest otherwise.

: Tue May 12, 2009 2:30 pm  

tvoc wrote:

The league table and who is in and out of the Challenge Cup would suggest otherwise.

The giant's got lucky with the draw and haven't suffered half the injurie's wakey have. H-T-H