2009 Match Rating Thread - Part 2 : Sat Apr 18, 2009 7:34 pm  

Couldn't find the other one.

Leeds v Huddersfield

Brent Webb 8 - Two good tries, caught everything well, good performance.
Scott Donald 4 - I don't know if it's his injury and a bit of rust but he was shocking. Get him back on the left.
Ashley Gibson 6 - Did nothing wrong, but nothing special. Average.
Keith Senior 7 - Good assist for the Hall try, created a few chances.
Ryan Hall 6 - A bit quiet, but well taken try.
Danny McGuire 8 - Him and Burrow were working as a unit tonight, alot better.
Rob Burrow 8 - Same as above
Ian Kirke 6 - Good yards, a couple of errors and penalties though.
Matt Diskin 7 - Better second spell, did well to take the try although it shouldn't have been given IMO.
Jamie Peacock 8 - Great performance, always made the most metres.
JJB 6 - Nothing special.
Ablett 5 - Too many errors and silly penalties, he needs to cut it out of his game.
Sinfield 8 - Not MOM like on Sky but good kicking game, great 40-20.

Buderus 9 - MOM - Best performance in a Leeds shirt, fantastic break, second time in two games he has done that now and the distribution to the forwards and halves from dummy half is brilliant.
Ali 6 - Quiet.
Burgess 7 - Good go forward
Bailey 5 - Hardly remember him having the ball, also sloppy defending that led to one of their breaks, but I can't remember if it was the break that led to the try.

Re: 2009 Match Rating Thread - Part 2 : Sat Apr 18, 2009 7:43 pm  

efcrhino wrote:

Burgess 7 - Good go forward

shocking in defence by him n bailey on Robinson, didn't notice much else from him

Re: 2009 Match Rating Thread - Part 2 : Sat Apr 18, 2009 8:05 pm  

MHL wrote:

shocking in defence by him n bailey on Robinson, didn't notice much else from him

A couple of Burgess' shots tonight on opposition forwards running drop outs etc in were huge.

One on Crabtree and I think one on Mason.

There was a good hit by Buderus on Mason too i thought

: Sat Apr 18, 2009 8:09 pm  

Hardman Bailey was anonymous tonight, rarely took the ball up and looked a shadow of the "enforcer" he has looked in recent weeks.

: Sat Apr 18, 2009 8:54 pm  

~ No1 Saints Fan ~ wrote:

Hardman Bailey was anonymous tonight, rarely took the ball up and looked a shadow of the "enforcer" he has looked in recent weeks.

Nah he didn't because he is just saving himself for his BIATCHES James Graham & Maurie Fa'asavalu...

: Sat Apr 18, 2009 8:56 pm  

Thought out of all our forwards Bailey got the quiker play the ball and we seemed to get forward quicker after his drives.

Re: 2009 Match Rating Thread - Part 2 : Sat Apr 18, 2009 11:28 pm  

efcrhino wrote:

Couldn't find the other one.

Leeds v Huddersfield

Brent Webb 8 - Two good tries, caught everything well, good performance.
Scott Donald 4 - I don't know if it's his injury and a bit of rust but he was shocking. Get him back on the left.
Ashley Gibson 6 - Did nothing wrong, but nothing special. Average.
Keith Senior 7 - Good assist for the Hall try, created a few chances.
Ryan Hall 6 - A bit quiet, but well taken try.
Danny McGuire 8 - Him and Burrow were working as a unit tonight, alot better.
Rob Burrow 8 - Same as above
Ian Kirke 6 - Good yards, a couple of errors and penalties though.
Matt Diskin 7 - Better second spell, did well to take the try although it shouldn't have been given IMO.
Jamie Peacock 8 - Great performance, always made the most metres.
JJB 6 - Nothing special.
Ablett 5 - Too many errors and silly penalties, he needs to cut it out of his game.
Sinfield 8 - Not MOM like on Sky but good kicking game, great 40-20.

Buderus 9 - MOM - Best performance in a Leeds shirt, fantastic break, second time in two games he has done that now and the distribution to the forwards and halves from dummy half is brilliant.
Ali 6 - Quiet.
Burgess 7 - Good go forward
Bailey 5 - Hardly remember him having the ball, also sloppy defending that led to one of their breaks, but I can't remember if it was the break that led to the try.

Think I can safely say that most of these match ratings are crap.

HTH

Re: 2009 Match Rating Thread - Part 2 : Sat Apr 18, 2009 11:33 pm  

EmmaMur01 wrote:

Think I can safely say that most of these match ratings are crap.

HTH

You beat me to it.

The OP clearly doesn't understand the game at all.

Re: 2009 Match Rating Thread - Part 2 : Sun Apr 19, 2009 12:00 am  

efcrhino wrote:

Couldn't find the other one.

Leeds v Huddersfield

Brent Webb 8 - Two good tries, caught everything well, good performance.
Scott Donald 4 - I don't know if it's his injury and a bit of rust but he was shocking. Get him back on the left.
Ashley Gibson 6 - Did nothing wrong, but nothing special. Average.
Keith Senior 7 - Good assist for the Hall try, created a few chances.
Ryan Hall 6 - A bit quiet, but well taken try.
Danny McGuire 8 - Him and Burrow were working as a unit tonight, alot better.
Rob Burrow 8 - Same as above
Ian Kirke 6 - Good yards, a couple of errors and penalties though.
Matt Diskin 7 - Better second spell, did well to take the try although it shouldn't have been given IMO.
Jamie Peacock 8 - Great performance, always made the most metres.
JJB 6 - Nothing special.
Ablett 5 - Too many errors and silly penalties, he needs to cut it out of his game.
Sinfield 8 - Not MOM like on Sky but good kicking game, great 40-20.

Buderus 9 - MOM - Best performance in a Leeds shirt, fantastic break, second time in two games he has done that now and the distribution to the forwards and halves from dummy half is brilliant.
Ali 6 - Quiet.
Burgess 7 - Good go forward
Bailey 5 - Hardly remember him having the ball, also sloppy defending that led to one of their breaks, but I can't remember if it was the break that led to the try.

What a load of bollox.

You conveniently missed Webb doing the self same thing as donald but because its Webb it's ignored.

Donald dropped it twice, so what. Not the best game but A 4? What a joke.

JJB worked very hard as did Ali.

You pick up on Baileys sloppy defence yet ignore the same by Burgess,

Buderus a 9. Where is the emoticon for shakes head and walks away?

Re: 2009 Match Rating Thread - Part 2 : Sun Apr 19, 2009 12:03 am  

efcrhino wrote:

Couldn't find the other one.

Leeds v Huddersfield

Brent Webb 7
Scott Donald 5
Ashley Gibson 6
Keith Senior 7
Ryan Hall 6.
Danny McGuire 8
Rob Burrow 8
Ian Kirke 7
Matt Diskin 7
Jamie Peacock6
JJB 7
Ablett 5
Sinfield 7.

Buderus 7
Ali 7
Burgess 6
Bailey 6

None of them were brilliant because Leeds can be a lot better, and individual performances can be better.
Having said that it was a good win, and confidence grew thoughout the match.