Re: IN 2024 | Brodie Croft - Expires: 2026 : Sun Oct 22, 2023 8:21 pm  

chapylad wrote:

Lewis looked good today JB and if as everyone is saying that Croft is better, then we have got one hell of a player.
I personally would have preferred Lewis on much less money, less of a transfer fee and wouldn`t have taken an overseas spot.
I must admit that I have not seen much of Croft but have seen a dozen or so games with Lewis playing.

But do you think Hull KR would have sold him? There's a lot of money in that club now. The polar opposite of Salford. Croft is an excellent player. He'll do fine, trust me.

Re: IN 2024 | Brodie Croft - Expires: 2026 : Mon Oct 23, 2023 1:57 am  

I actually don't think Lewis was as good today as the BBC commentators thought he was. The first break was good work following a nice read by Clark to recognise where the space was, having a player who can exploit broken field is always invaluable, as there usually isn't much of it at test level, so that's definitely a major positive in his favour.
As for his try, I actually thought he was lucky the Tongan defence (was it Tui?) totally misread the situation, the majority of time, even SL he would be wrapped up there. He should really have passed to Makinson for a walk in.
His defence is also nowhere near the level of Williams, and at least 1 of the 3 ball steals he committed led to a try being conceded.

Re: IN 2024 | Brodie Croft - Expires: 2026 : Mon Oct 23, 2023 3:55 pm  

chapylad wrote:

Lewis looked good today JB and if as everyone is saying that Croft is better, then we have got one hell of a player.
I personally would have preferred Lewis on much less money, less of a transfer fee and wouldn`t have taken an overseas spot.
I must admit that I have not seen much of Croft but have seen a dozen or so games with Lewis playing.

Lewis will not bring the structure Croft does and forget about his wage only 150K counts against the cap