Sat Jan 17, 2015 9:57 pm
BackrowSaint wrote:Doesn't appear to be much quality on that list. Retaining Walsh should be the main priority but seems unlikely that we'll be able to.
Sun Jan 18, 2015 12:11 am
The Yellow Giraffe wrote:I think we'll get another year out of him after this one. If Walsh was to leave then Dureau would be a fine replacement.
I wouldn't mind seeing us make a move for Elliott Whitehead.
Sun Jan 18, 2015 12:12 am
Magic Superbeetle wrote:I'm not sure we stand much chance with Walsh, especially after reading what kc said on the matter, but I hope and pray! There's a few big hitters on the market in aus next year, so we might be able to get the signature early before the DCE/ Foran losers come looking for consolations.
I'd rather have Ferres than Whitehead imo, but I imagine well re-sign Wilkin over bringing in anyone else in the second row ...
Sun Jan 18, 2015 12:16 am
The Yellow Giraffe wrote:Which comments from KC are you referring to? The last thing I read was KC saying he hopes Walsh and Burns will play together for a few years.
Luke has an option on a third year – it is in his favour, but if he is enjoying his rugby and things are going well I’d like to think we can have some influence in his future,” he said.
Sun Jan 18, 2015 12:21 am
Magic Superbeetle wrote:You mean?
http://www.sthelensstar.co.uk/sport/117 ... yond_2015/
Sounds like a hit and hope to me, unfortunately. Just doesn't fill me with confidence
Sun Jan 18, 2015 6:41 am
Sun Jan 18, 2015 8:55 am
Sun Jan 18, 2015 12:48 pm
SecondRowSaint wrote:Doesn't look much in the way of replacing Walsh IF he does leave. Like you said Dureau would be decent but if he manages to find his form of his first season for Cats as last year he was nowhere near that good IMO. Other than him at half back there's only Liam Finn who I feel was at his peak season just gone and wouldn't be good enough for where we need to be at. There's also Myler but he still needs to develop his all round game for me.
Looking at the NRL, not sure who we'd be able to punt for from these;
http://www.zerotackle.com/nrl/rugby-lea ... ract-2015/
As for other positions, i'd definitely take one of Ferres or Whitehead to run at second row or even Grant Millington to play as loose/second row. Props wise I'd go with one of the French lads either Benjamin Garcia, Antoni Maria or maybe Craig Kopzcak. Doesn't look much in the way of backs who would be attainable, potentially Oldfield but we are fine on the wings for now.
But like Backrow Saint said, there's not much quality on that list.
Sun Jan 18, 2015 1:12 pm
Magic Superbeetle wrote:Unless we let Jones or Dawson go, would we need to bring in any more backs though? After getting Walsh signed for any price necessary, recruitment definitely has to be forwards focussed.
Would we have to re-sign/ replace Hohaia? Could Charnock step up and fill that 14 role? How likely is Masoe to stay/ do people want him to etc if he does go, I wouldn't mind going for Tasi, who seemed to be one of the few good pickups Salford had last year. The second row seems to have the best recruitment options but would we need another with Greenwood, Thompson, Savelio all pushing through?
(YG: I'm sure we'd all prefer that logic but maybe I'm just a pessimist on the matter! )
Sun Jan 18, 2015 3:03 pm
The Yellow Giraffe wrote:Haha I'm a glass half full man!
Hohaia is an interesting one. For his first 2 years most Saints fans wanted rid of him, and I'm sure some still do. But last year he actually had a decent year.
He has terrific utility value and I'm sure having him there will help give Roby a breather.
I wouldn't be dead against him signing a 1 or 2 year extension, providing it was on reduced terms as he simply doesn't warrant "marquee" status.
However if freeing up his wage meant keeping Walsh and signing Whitehead/Ferres then we should move him on. Charnock has played 1,6 and 9 so maybe he could replace that utility spot.