Re: Silverthon to take charge on Friday : Wed Apr 22, 2009 4:02 pm  

DILLIGAF wrote:

Difference being, the Leeds try, the ball was clearly touched. The only question was if it went forward or backward.

In 1999, there was no evidence whatsoever to suggest the ball was touched and yet it was still ruled a knock on. And yes, I still abuse the tv every time they show that.

Mick assured me and others that he never touched it.

Re: Silverthon to take charge on Friday : Wed Apr 22, 2009 4:04 pm  

Adeybull wrote:

Mick assured me and others that he never touched it.

How could he have touched it? He will have been in the stands singing. You've got to joke.

: Wed Apr 22, 2009 4:17 pm  

I hope Bradford win.

: Wed Apr 22, 2009 4:36 pm  

Leeds Rhinos Superman wrote:

I hope Bradford win.

Macca will loose just to pi$$ off the Rhions Give the man a new contract

: Wed Apr 22, 2009 5:24 pm  

All I/m going to say on the matter is that once again Cummings has played a great hand in the referee allocations. Remember this anyone from last year?? http://www.thetelegraphandargus.co.uk/s ... hes_Bulls/ After the game Cummings came out to say that "Bradford should have been given more penalties and that some of the penalties to St Helens should not have been given" I do and at the risk of getting banned, I will say no more.

All I/m going to say on the matter is that once again Cummings has played a great hand in the referee allocations. Remember this anyone from last year?? http://www.thetelegraphandargus.co.uk/s ... hes_Bulls/ After the game Cummings came out to say that "Bradford should have been given more penalties and that some of the penalties to St Helens should not have been given" I do and at the risk of getting banned, I will say no more.

: Wed Apr 22, 2009 5:43 pm  

In the last 11 games in that we have had the Silverthon we have only won two games .

I'm not saying he is bent against the Bulls but it doesn't look good does it ???

When we have played teams like Catalans, Wakefield, Hull KR, Hull Fc etc.


Sat, 28th July 2007 Bradford Bulls 14 v St Helens 35, Referee: Richard Silverwood (LOST)

Fri, 14th September 2007 Hull FC 20 v Bradford Bulls 10, Referee: Richard Silverwood (LOST)

Sun, 10th February 2008 Wakefield Trinity Wildcats 26 v Bradford Bulls 24, Referee: Richard Silverwood (LOST)

Sat, 1st March 2008 Wigan Warriors 28 v Bradford Bulls 14, Referee: Richard Silverwood (LOST)

Sun, 16th March 2008 Bradford Bulls 23 v Warrington Wolves 10, Referee: Richard Silverwood (WON)

Sun, 13th April 2008 Hull Kingston Rovers 20 v Bradford Bulls 18, Referee: Richard Silverwood (LOST)

Sat, 3rd May 2008 Leeds Rhinos 40 v Bradford Bulls 26, Referee: Richard Silverwood (LOST)

Sun, 8th June 2008 Bradford Bulls 16 v Catalans Dragons 24, Referee: Richard Silverwood (LOST)

Fri, 13th June 2008 St Helens 58 v Bradford Bulls 20, Referee: Richard Silverwood (LOST)

Mon, 25th August 2008 Bradford Bulls 42 v Hull Kingston Rovers 18, Referee: Richard Silverwood (WON)

Mon, 13th April 2009 Wakefield Wildcats 24 v Bradford Bulls 22, Referee: Richard Silverwood (LOST)

: Wed Apr 22, 2009 8:29 pm  

Stirlingshire Saint wrote:

To be honest, when you're turning up to play at Saints with the combined brilliance of Ricki Sheriffe, Michael Platt, Paul Sykes etc I don't think the referee will come into it.

You know, a decent troll would have got a bite by now.

: Wed Apr 22, 2009 11:09 pm  

Mick Gledhill wrote:

In the last 11 games in that we have had the Silverthon

We've had Silverwood at home on 13 occasions, and won them all.

In away games, we've won 3, drawn 1 and lost 9. All 4 Saints "aways" he has reffed we have lost.

Silverwood has reffed St Helens 23 times at home.. They have won 22 of these.
Of 19 games away from KR, the record is W 12 - D 1 - L 6

Saints have never won at Odsal with Silverwood reffing. This includes Mon 12 Apr 2004 when the score was Bradford 54-8 St Helens.

Our record in SL at KR is Won 7 Lost 13. The only refs who have officiated Bradford wins are Russell Smith, Cummings, Presley, Bob Connolly, Klein and Kirkpatrick.

: Thu Apr 23, 2009 6:58 am  

Ferocious Aardvark wrote:

We've had Silverwood at home on 13 occasions, and won them all.

In away games, we've won 3, drawn 1 and lost 9. All 4 Saints "aways" he has reffed we have lost.

Silverwood has reffed St Helens 23 times at home.. They have won 22 of these.
Of 19 games away from KR, the record is W 12 - D 1 - L 6

Saints have never won at Odsal with Silverwood reffing. This includes Mon 12 Apr 2004 when the score was Bradford 54-8 St Helens.

Our record in SL at KR is Won 7 Lost 13. The only refs who have officiated Bradford wins are Russell Smith, Cummings, Presley, Bob Connolly, Klein and Kirkpatrick.

We are not worthy.

: Thu Apr 23, 2009 8:11 am  

tigertot wrote:

:BOW:
We are not worthy.

Well I know this, obviously