I think most of the negative stuff has come from Wakey fans and stems from his time there. It's fair to say he didn't have the best of times at Belle Vue, but there were reasons , mainly injuries and by his own admission he was never 100% fit when there.
To be honest, I've no idea how he dropped form being the NRL 'wunderkind', to signing for us, a championship club, here in the UK. Maybe that is injury related too, I dunno.
With the kicking, I can only assume he's been best in practice. He missed a couple at Cas, in the wind and quite well out but seemed to be quite near. Again at Headingley he missed two from well out, though I couldn't see how close he was from the west terrace - maybe he was close again?