Re: What does your first 17 look like for 2019? : Fri Nov 02, 2018 1:13 pm  

roger daly wrote:

I would think Crossley will be captain, with my lad vice captain, as it was for last couple of month of this season. Not heard anything that’s just my opinion

in your first 17, would you have your lad at SR or LF?

Re: What does your first 17 look like for 2019? : Fri Nov 02, 2018 1:19 pm  

Top 5 for me this year:

Toronto
Widnes
Toulouse
Halifax
Bradford

I think this year with a fairly stable good team we have a really decent chance teams such as fev and Dewsbury and Sheffield have had massive turnovers of players we have been stable though fev I admit have got the boas brothers they have a young squad and though there forwards look big, playing in the Academy and having Ross Peltier running at you he’ll for leather on a cold rainy February are 2 different things

Re: What does your first 17 look like for 2019? : Fri Nov 02, 2018 1:26 pm  

scorchingdick wrote:

in your first 17, would you have your lad at SR or LF?

Sub.

I think he’s better at loose with the freedom it gives him to roam about, but having said that a lot of his tries backing up this season were from 2nd row. I do think he’s a better loose than a 2nd row though

Re: What does your first 17 look like for 2019? : Fri Nov 02, 2018 1:28 pm  

scorchingdick wrote:

Pickersgill

close call between green and magrin

No comparison in my opinion. Green seriously impressed me in the short time he was with us this year. Magrin is solid if unspectacular. Green has a dangerous offloading game as well as some decent mongrel returning the ball. Obviously all about opinion, be a boring place if we all shared the same. I think Bustin will be the one competing with magrin for the 4th prop spot. Be interesting how he steps up to the championship (not that im doubting he can) as all his first team experience has been in league 1 so far

Re: What does your first 17 look like for 2019? : Fri Nov 02, 2018 1:38 pm  

McNally definitely to start the season and hopefully he has better luck with injuries this time. Pickersgill could well be first choice FB by the end of the season.

McNally
Hitchcox
Webster
Gibson
Ryan
Keyes
Chisholm
Crossley
Wildie
Green
Minchella
Storton
Wood

Peltier
Bustin
Farrell
Flanagan

Not as easy as it looks is it!

[Bullseye]

Re: What does your first 17 look like for 2019? : Fri Nov 02, 2018 1:47 pm  

thepimp007 wrote:

No comparison in my opinion. Green seriously impressed me in the short time he was with us this year. Magrin is solid if unspectacular. Green has a dangerous offloading game as well as some decent mongrel returning the ball. Obviously all about opinion, be a boring place if we all shared the same. I think Bustin will be the one competing with magrin for the 4th prop spot. Be interesting how he steps up to the championship (not that im doubting he can) as all his first team experience has been in league 1 so far

If Bustin can get fit he'll go really well, he did look a bit overweight at the back end of the year and if I was a halfback or speedy hooker I'd be looking to exploit him in defence as he sometimes plants his feet or is slow getting up and working from marker. Funnily enough it's defence where I think Kirk really shines but he doesn't take the ball up and make yards like Bustin.

I think Green is a real plus off the bench with Peltier. Magrin's steady as you say - I'd have him as 5th choice.

Re: What does your first 17 look like for 2019? : Fri Nov 02, 2018 1:56 pm  

From the thread, we look to have some real depth for a long hard season.

I think Toronto, Toulouse & Widnes are nailed on for the play-offs. I think it will be a fight between us, York, Fev, Fax & Sheffield for the other two spots.

The signings Fev have made look real quality. However they have lost a lot of players and don't seem to have a huge amount signed up (happy to be corrected Fev fans) think their starting 17 can beat anyone, but a few injuries and they may struggle.

Fax are always competitive and always difficult to beat. There seems some frustration on their board at lack of recruitment but i expect them to be there or there abouts

York are riding a crest of a wave and Sheffield look to be gathering a handy team, similar to one thats brought then success in the past.

While last season was a bore, next season looks like its gonna be a cracker.

[Bullseye]

Re: What does your first 17 look like for 2019? : Fri Nov 02, 2018 2:24 pm  

Fev will also have dual reg with Leeds so I fully expect them to be in with a shout of the 5.

Fax should also be in the 5. They've done the business for the past few years and know what it takes to get there. That's our main weakness IMO, we look great on paper but we're coming off the back of a season in L1 and it will be much much tougher in 2019. Some of our new recruits know what it takes in the championship but it will be a shock to some others.

Re: What does your first 17 look like for 2019? : Fri Nov 02, 2018 3:06 pm  

thepimp007 wrote:

No comparison in my opinion. Green seriously impressed me in the short time he was with us this year. Magrin is solid if unspectacular. Green has a dangerous offloading game as well as some decent mongrel returning the ball. Obviously all about opinion, be a boring place if we all shared the same. I think Bustin will be the one competing with magrin for the 4th prop spot. Be interesting how he steps up to the championship (not that im doubting he can) as all his first team experience has been in league 1 so far

i dont really disagree with you
i think i was swayed by magrin already having a few years experience in the championship and looking solid last time he was with us

Re: What does your first 17 look like for 2019? : Fri Nov 02, 2018 5:37 pm  

McNally
Hitchcox
Webster
Gibson
Ryan
Keyes
Chisholm
Crossley
Wildie
Green
Garside
Minchella
Wood

Peltier
Magrin
Flanagan/Lilley- probably rotate
Farrell