: Tue Mar 10, 2009 6:55 pm  

rhinoms wrote:

Andy farrell was awarded the golden boot in 2004,james roby won the man of steel in 2007 and just like fielden's these awards were laughable.
In the context of the world's best forward fielden was never any better than civenceva,price,tallis,fitzgibbon etc.

In other words awards/trophies only count for something when leeds are involved

: Tue Mar 10, 2009 7:00 pm  

mat wrote:

In other words awards/trophies only count for something when leeds are involved

No not at all mate i just think even though he was the best by a mile at his peak over here when you talk world's best then at that time there were better forwards in the NRL.
If sam B can continue to develop and mcbanana doesn't run him into the ground he imo will be a golden boot winner one day.
Also i'm sure you'll agree many fans of the game have differing opinion's when the awards are dished out but if you differ to mcbanana's cheerleader FA'S opinion then all the bile comes out.

: Tue Mar 10, 2009 8:20 pm  

SDB wrote:

but in the Hudds match on 3 sucessive sets Burgess took 3 drives in each

Thats a load of bo%&$cks

: Tue Mar 10, 2009 9:01 pm  

i have heard from a very good source that he will be going down under after his bulls contract!

: Tue Mar 10, 2009 11:40 pm  

rhinoms wrote:

:lol:
No not at all mate i just think even though he was the best by a mile at his peak over here when you talk world's best then at that time there were better forwards in the NRL.

In the opinion of a poor internet troll, but on the day, a panel of experts who know a good player when they see one disagreed. Nobody says you aren't entitled to an opinion, but you have to admit you are to informed opinion what Toulouse Lautrec was to pole vaulting

rhinoms wrote:

Also I'm sure you'll agree many fans of the game have differing opinion's when the awards are dished out but if you differ to mcbanana's cheerleader FA'S opinion then all the bile comes out.

As it was not I who awarded him the title, that's just more bollox. I don't recall any "bile" coming out, I just pointed out what a fool you had made of yourself. I'm not responsible for your delusions of grandeur

: Wed Mar 11, 2009 1:18 am  

Ferocious Aardvark wrote:

In the opinion of a poor internet troll, but on the day, a panel of experts who know a good player when they see one disagreed. Nobody says you aren't entitled to an opinion, but you have to admit you are to informed opinion what Toulouse Lautrec was to pole vaulting


As it was not I who awarded him the title, that's just more bollox. I don't recall any "bile" coming out, I just pointed out what a fool you had made of yourself. I'm not responsible for your delusions of grandeur

The very same experts who awarded it to farrell???
IF you look at who was around and on the top of their game when fielden got his award then it's safe to say that there were candidates who'd done better both domestically in a harder league and on the international stage.
Again you resort to petty insults because i don't agree with your opinion or that of an award received by a bulls player(which has nothing to do with my opinion).
Like i said previous there's no doubt he was the best over here but imo not better than the ones i listed that is of course if i'm allowed an opinion.
Yet again anyone who disagree's with you are labelled trolls
What next FA??
Are gonna tell me mcnamara is the best english coach out there??
That your signings are quality??
Or just petty insults and name calling because we disagree!!

: Wed Mar 11, 2009 1:22 am  

rhinoms wrote:

The very same experts who awarded it to farrell???
IF you look at who was around and on the top of their game when fielden got his award then it's safe to say that there were candidates who'd done better both domestically in a harder league and on the international stage.
Again you resort to petty insults because i don't agree with your opinion or that of an award received by a bulls player(which has nothing to do with my opinion).
Like i said previous there's no doubt he was the best over here but imo not better than the ones i listed that is of course if i'm allowed an opinion.
Yet again anyone who disagree's with you are labelled trolls
What next FA??
Are gonna tell me mcnamara is the best english coach out there??
That your signings are quality??
Or just petty insults and name calling because we disagree!!

You know nothing about Rugby League.

: Wed Mar 11, 2009 1:33 am  

Ashmeister wrote:

You know nothing about Rugby League.

So come on then brain of britain enlighten me!!!
So in 2004 i disagree farrell was the best player in the world or that fielden was the best forward on 05 means i know nothing??
Next you'll be telling me roby deserved his man of steel over barrett and pryce in 07.
Jog on fella it's called an opinion and the quality around imo was better than the ones who got their awards.
E.g In 04 lets take farrell he won the golden boot over the likes of andrew johns,darren lockyer,gordon tallis,civeneciva!!
Then fielden won the best forward in the world over the likes of steve price,civenaceva,willie mason,fitzgibbon,wiki,kearney.
There's no doubt they were the best english players in their positions but not at international level imo.

: Wed Mar 11, 2009 1:46 am  

rhinoms wrote:

So come on then brain of britain enlighten me!!!
So in 2004 i disagree farrell was the best player in the world or that fielden was the best forward on 05 means i know nothing??
Next you'll be telling me roby deserved his man of steel over barrett and pryce in 07.
Jog on fella it's called an opinion and the quality around imo was better than the ones who got their awards.
E.g In 04 lets take farrell he won the golden boot over the likes of andrew johns,darren lockyer,gordon tallis,civeneciva!!
Then fielden won the best forward in the world over the likes of steve price,civenaceva,willie mason,fitzgibbon,wiki,kearney.
There's no doubt they were the best english players in their positions but not at international level imo.

Like i said pal! You know nothing.

: Wed Mar 11, 2009 1:49 am  

Ashmeister wrote:

Like i said pal! You know nothing.

If you say so
I like the way you've proved your argument and put your well thought out response into words