[Bulliac]

Re: Cobb : Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:18 am  

Alan wrote:

On the subject of SL referees, is it just my imagination that they allow defenders more time to clear the tackle, than Championship refs do?

I'm surprised you say that since I've thought it was the opposite. In the championship refs seem to run the game at the speed of the slowest team whilst SL refs seem to run at the speed of the fastest, if I'm honest it's one of the most infuriating aspects of this division.

Re: Cobb : Tue Sep 08, 2015 10:51 am  

Bulliac wrote:

I'm surprised you say that since I've thought it was the opposite. In the championship refs seem to run the game at the speed of the slowest team whilst SL refs seem to run at the speed of the fastest, if I'm honest it's one of the most infuriating aspects of this division.

indeed, some of the holding down and lying-on we've had to put up with this season has been awful to watch and has degraded many a game.

Re: Cobb : Tue Sep 08, 2015 6:03 pm  

Ah Vans second try should have been made chalked off for a foot in touch too, no excuse for a touch judge missing that right in front of him. I thought it had at the time, but obviously I was a lot further away than the blind touchie. Let's hope we don't miss out on points difference because of poor refereeing. At the end of the day though, we need to be better and our defence was just too soft in that 2nd half. It was disappointing to see our effort levels dip once the result was beyond us.

Re: Cobb : Tue Sep 08, 2015 8:18 pm  

Bulliac wrote:

I'm surprised you say that since I've thought it was the opposite. In the championship refs seem to run the game at the speed of the slowest team whilst SL refs seem to run at the speed of the fastest, if I'm honest it's one of the most infuriating aspects of this division.

To me, the PTB's seem to have been slower, during our Qualifiers, with Thaler, Silverwood and Child (twice) in charge.

[Bulliac]

Re: Cobb : Wed Sep 09, 2015 10:18 am  

Bully_Boxer wrote:

Ah Vans second try should have been made chalked off for a foot in touch too, no excuse for a touch judge missing that right in front of him. I thought it had at the time, but obviously I was a lot further away than the blind touchie. Let's hope we don't miss out on points difference because of poor refereeing. At the end of the day though, we need to be better and our defence was just too soft in that 2nd half. It was disappointing to see our effort levels dip once the result was beyond us.

To be fair, the touchie did spot it and held his ground by the corner flag instead of running to the goal line, as he would if he'd thought it OK. Cobb just overruled him, presumably.

[Bulliac]

Re: Cobb : Wed Sep 09, 2015 10:27 am  

Alan wrote:

To me, the PTB's seem to have been slower, during our Qualifiers, with Thaler, Silverwood and Child (twice) in charge.

To be honest, I feel Thaler is probably the best ref in the game at the moment [opinion formed watching games on Sky] and Silverwood is usually pretty decent. All refs, like players and the rest of us, have their good and bad days of course, and commit howlers from time to time. Never liked Mr Child though, far more capricious [think that's the right word..] than most and universally hated at Odsal - not as much as another bloke I could mention though....I do wonder if they base decisions on the fact that the crowd don't like them?

Re: Cobb : Wed Sep 09, 2015 11:07 am  

Maybe he could follow in the footsteps of another crowd favourite, Ashley Klein, and sod off to annoy them in Oz.

Re: Cobb : Wed Sep 09, 2015 11:21 am  

Bulliac wrote:

To be fair, the touchie did spot it and held his ground by the corner flag instead of running to the goal line, as he would if he'd thought it OK. Cobb just overruled him, presumably.

If the touch judge had ruled a foot in touch he would surely of raised his flag?

Re: Cobb : Wed Sep 09, 2015 12:10 pm  

Bulliac wrote:

To be fair, the touchie did spot it and held his ground by the corner flag instead of running to the goal line, as he would if he'd thought it OK. Cobb just overruled him, presumably.

Yes I noticed he did that too. trouble is, i can't find anything in the rules about it. It seems if he rules a player did go into touch then he MUST immediately raise his flag and that's it, the ref cannot overrule him. But he didn't raise his flag. So I presume he had a doubt. Which Cobb ignored. Bad though Cobb was, if the touchie is NOT saying Paddy stepped into touch, and there's no VR option, what else can he do but award a try?

Re: Cobb : Wed Sep 09, 2015 2:07 pm  

Bulliac wrote:

To be honest, I feel Thaler is probably the best ref in the game at the moment [opinion formed watching games on Sky] and Silverwood is usually pretty decent. All refs, like players and the rest of us, have their good and bad days of course, and commit howlers from time to time. Never liked Mr Child though, far more capricious [think that's the right word..] than most and universally hated at Odsal - not as much as another bloke I could mention though....I do wonder if they base decisions on the fact that the crowd don't like them?

Thaler's the best we have had. (in one victory and one defeat) Seems to have a good rapport with the players, and actually knew the Christian names of our players, ("Get back Sam, leave it Sam, walk away Sam" ) rather than call them all "you" a la Silverwood, who has been admittedly better (in two defeats) than Child. (one victory, one defeat and one draw)

Of course, Cobb has been much better than any of the above!! (in two victories)