Re: Ownership and twists : Sat May 17, 2014 12:34 pm  

roofaldo2 wrote:

There's still no movement on the whole appeal. I thought it was supposed to have happened this week?

Appeal was put back to end of month last week. Strangely enough same day whitcut had his rant on twitter.

[Bulliac]

Re: Ownership and twists : Sun May 18, 2014 9:20 am  

If they can put it off until the end of the season we'll no longer be in SL, so it can then be left to some sub-committee to sort out. They'll probably then decide to give us all the points back, to be used the next time [if ever] we get back in SL - though they'll only be valid up the end of 2015..a bit like those million and a half free texts you get from the phone company which have to be used over the weekend.

Re: Ownership and twists : Sun May 18, 2014 1:14 pm  

Bulliac wrote:

If they can put it off until the end of the season we'll no longer be in SL, so it can then be left to some sub-committee to sort out. They'll probably then decide to give us all the points back, to be used the next time [if ever] we get back in SL - though they'll only be valid up the end of 2015..a bit like those million and a half free texts you get from the phone company which have to be used over the weekend.

Bulliac - don't give them ideas

Re: Ownership and twists : Sun May 18, 2014 6:56 pm  

You never know. The RFL may have a text vote on how many points we should be deducted. Who'll be laughing then.

Re: Ownership and twists : Sun May 18, 2014 8:35 pm  

Of course, the RFL advising the trio to go for admin is completely within the rules. Membership bye-laws:

4.8 The (RFL) Board has the right (but not obligation) to stipulate in advance of an Acquisition, Change of Control or Insolvency Event, whether or not a member will be readmitted or a new member admitted in such circumstances and to stipulate what terms it will apply.

If the RFL can advise in this way, and did so to the trio, then it cannot be force majeure of itself, there must be something else outside the rfl and the trios control that f'd up the plan. which was what?

Re: Ownership and twists : Sun May 18, 2014 11:21 pm  

Nobody really has a clue as to the stated grounds of appeal. Other than one-phrase reports about "force majeure", no details have emerged that I have seen. If it was just that, then frankly I have no clue what they mean or how that might work, and so I sort of assume it's not, as surely we would not lodge and pursue an appeal of pure bullcrap, but who knows.

Re: Ownership and twists : Mon May 19, 2014 7:13 am  

martinwildbull wrote:

Of course, the RFL advising the trio to go for admin is completely within the rules. Membership bye-laws:

4.8 The (RFL) Board has the right (but not obligation) to stipulate in advance of an Acquisition, Change of Control or Insolvency Event, whether or not a member will be readmitted or a new member admitted in such circumstances and to stipulate what terms it will apply.

If the RFL can advise in this way, and did so to the trio, then it cannot be force majeure of itself, there must be something else outside the rfl and the trios control that f'd up the plan. which was what?

But that can also mean that the RFL said to the trio "Go into Admin to get rid of OK, we'll take care of it so you won't have a points deduction"

[Bulliac]

Re: Ownership and twists : Mon May 19, 2014 7:46 am  

I think, as I once posted before, that much will depend on the terms of reference and conditions of the 'review'.

I'm guessing here, but I expect the RFL commissioned the review so will have drawn up these terms of reference. Whether they are actually bright enough to skew these in their favour is open to question, though we can only assume the will have tried.

Personally, I hope the the RFL's conduct with Omar and with Moore et al [in the gospel according to Ryan W] is looked at by the inquiry, though I suspect all that may well be outside the terms of reference.

Re: Ownership and twists : Mon May 19, 2014 10:45 am  

Well, the appeal seems to be grinding it's way along. I wonder how the club's "root & branch" review is coming along. Not really heard much from the club since Ferres' verbal blast after Easter Monday.

Re: Ownership and twists : Mon May 19, 2014 12:04 pm  

Highlander wrote:

Well, the appeal seems to be grinding it's way along. I wonder how the club's "root & branch" review is coming along. Not really heard much from the club since Ferres' verbal blast after Easter Monday.

Perhaps they are leaving it to a bit latter in the season by which time we will know which "branch" of the leagues we will have our "roots" in. Either that or someone has lost both the root and the branch during the multiple administrations and ownership wrangles.

Nearly got to 400 pages on the thread