Re: Your Bulls 2011 Starting 17 : Mon Jan 31, 2011 9:23 am  

After his pre season performances, Ian Sibbit will be pushing Whitehead close for the starting backrow spot. Allthough I think Potter will probably opt for him off the bench to provide a bit of impact. Could never understand the criticism that Sibbit got or why Potter was criticised for signing him. He's a good player and will do really well for us.

Kearney
Ah Van
Platt
Walker
Raynor
Briggs
Herbert
Lynch
Diskin
Hargreaves
Elima
Whitehead
Langley

Koppy
Scruton
L'estrange
Sibbit

Re: Your Bulls 2011 Starting 17 : Mon Jan 31, 2011 11:27 am  

Sibbit is a must in the squad on yesterdays performance imo. I actually like the look of the team above, as I thought Sykes didnt look as good as platt or walker yesterday. I am unsure on Raynor but he will only improve and because of the depth at centre, Ah Van will probably start at wing although he certainly looks like he could do a very good job in the centres.

I thought whitehead looked good but did seem to fall off a few tackles. I think we could be on trouble with the high kicks out wide this season so hopefully Potter works on this.

Re: Your Bulls 2011 Starting 17 : Mon Jan 31, 2011 12:40 pm  

bigchris wrote:

Kearney
Raynor
Ah Van
Platt
Ainscough
Briggs
Herbert
Hargreaves
Diskin
Lynch
Elima
Whitehead
Langely

Scruton
Koppy
L'Estrange
Walker

I'm sticking with my original squad after yesterday, with Sibbit pressing for a place if any of the pack don't perform.

Re: Your Bulls 2011 Starting 17 : Mon Jan 31, 2011 2:17 pm  

Bulls4Champs2010 wrote:

After his pre season performances, Ian Sibbit will be pushing Whitehead close for the starting backrow spot. Allthough I think Potter will probably opt for him off the bench to provide a bit of impact. Could never understand the criticism that Sibbit got or why Potter was criticised for signing him. He's a good player and will do really well for us.

Kearney
Ah Van
Platt
Walker
Raynor
Briggs
Herbert
Lynch
Diskin
Hargreaves
Elima
Whitehead
Langley

Koppy
Scruton
L'estrange
Sibbit

I'd go along with that one. only change I'd consider would be royston on bench instead of sibbit. depends whether we want to go for a power game, in which sibbit gets nod, or go more for skill in which case royston goes in. think platt is ahead of sykes by a long way for Centre berth now and whilst ainscough hasnt done anything wrong per se think platt and ah van is a better pairing for leeds.

Re: Your Bulls 2011 Starting 17 : Mon Jan 31, 2011 2:19 pm  

Nah to Royston on the bench. He hasnt impressed me. Dont think he offers more than Sibbitt.

Re: Your Bulls 2011 Starting 17 : Mon Jan 31, 2011 3:31 pm  

Bulls4Champs2010 wrote:

Nah to Royston on the bench. He hasnt impressed me. Dont think he offers more than Sibbitt.

the one thing he offers that sibbit doesnt is cover for the backs. If we lose a back to injury our only real option would be one off diskin or l'estrange dropping back. Whereas if a 2nd rower gets injured then walker could go into 2nd row and if a prop got injured then langley could move their. But on balance I'd probably take gamble that all backs would stay fit and use sibbit for this game. Think we need to think more in terms of having cover on bench later in season when people start carrying knocks.

Re: Your Bulls 2011 Starting 17 : Mon Jan 31, 2011 5:04 pm  

i think we need cover tbh, we have to have a back option on the bench with a full squad. 4 forwards on the bench usually takes place when clubs have injuries. Whilst Royson didnt blow me away, he would mean we could rejuggle to cover FB, loose, 2nd row, centre and the halfs. Plus his back up play is awesome

Re: Your Bulls 2011 Starting 17 : Mon Jan 31, 2011 5:27 pm  

slideby wrote:

i think we need cover tbh, we have to have a back option on the bench with a full squad. 4 forwards on the bench usually takes place when clubs have injuries. Whilst Royson didnt blow me away, he would mean we could rejuggle to cover FB, loose, 2nd row, centre and the halfs. Plus his back up play is awesome

all true, but for first game or two when everyones 100% fit then we can probably take gamble on not picking up any serious injuries and go for power on bench. As season progresses and we start picking up niggles it would certainly make sense to think in terms of having cover on bench. That said I think leeds will really miss JP and we could potentially look at having a back on bench and just go with 3 forwards and still overpower them in the forwards battle. given quality of leeds's backline it may be beneficial to have a fresh back available to come on at some stage. Bit of a selection headache for Potter but thats why he's the coach and we're just spectators I guess.

Re: Your Bulls 2011 Starting 17 : Mon Jan 31, 2011 7:43 pm  

My concern is that we will have a backline which includes:

Herbert- injured last year and took a knock other day
Walker- Back from serious injury
Kearney- Bad injuries previously and suffered a little last year
Briggs- Bit of a step up physically
Ah Van- Think he was injured last season

In addition Raynor hasnt had much action and langley has got a slight groin strain. Bit risky imo

Re: Your Bulls 2011 Starting 17 : Mon Jan 31, 2011 7:55 pm  

Herbert took a knock? These things happen and it was only precautionary him been taken off
Walker - gamble yes, in terms of fitness and whilst a bad brea he has come back and could provie a real bargain
Kearney - 1 bad injury as i recall, yes he got a knock last season but again, cant be helped
Briggs - possibly, possibly not
Ah Van - not picked last season by NZ Warriors as i understand