Re: Twelfth SL club for 2021 : Mon Aug 24, 2020 1:32 pm  

If Bradford or Fev are the answer the game is finished.

Re: Twelfth SL club for 2021 : Mon Aug 24, 2020 4:12 pm  

wire-quin wrote:

If Bradford or Fev are the answer the game is finished.

So who would you suggest and why ?

Fev (at least) were the club beaten by Toronto, which, due to the lack of RL since that game, puts them in poll position.
Personally, I'd like to see Toulouse take the spot but, despite being challengers and having had a decent start to the season, their would be very loud shouts of "FAVOURITISM" (or worse), if they got the nod.
Of the rest, you then look at Leigh, Widnes or London.
York, Bradford and Newcastle havent been in contention and to suddenly elevate any of these (or Bradford) would just be taking the Mickey although, in time, any of them could be proper contenders.

Re: Twelfth SL club for 2021 : Mon Aug 24, 2020 4:34 pm  

wrencat1873 wrote:

So who would you suggest and why ?

Fev (at least) were the club beaten by Toronto, which, due to the lack of RL since that game, puts them in poll position.
Personally, I'd like to see Toulouse take the spot but, despite being challengers and having had a decent start to the season, their would be very loud shouts of "FAVOURITISM" (or worse), if they got the nod.
Of the rest, you then look at Leigh, Widnes or London.
York, Bradford and Newcastle havent been in contention and to suddenly elevate any of these (or Bradford) would just be taking the Mickey although, in time, any of them could be proper contenders.

Has to be Leigh or Widnes if we are going down the traditional route.. The league needs another Yorkshire club without a pot to p!$s in, like it needs a hole in the head.

Personally, I'd sooner give a London or Newcastle a real prolonged go of things (proper 5-10 year licence) than simply kick the can down the road with a club which would only bring more mediocrity to the league, like Featherstone.

Re: Twelfth SL club for 2021 : Mon Aug 24, 2020 4:52 pm  

]

Dita's Slot Meter wrote:

Has to be Leigh or Widnes if we are going down the traditional route.. The league needs another Yorkshire club without a pot to p!$s in, like it needs a hole in the head.

Personally, I'd sooner give a London or Newcastle a real prolonged go of things (proper 5-10 year licence) than simply kick the can down the road with a club which would only bring more mediocrity to the league, like Featherstone.

It has to be Tolouse, London has been tried, and failed, Newcastle is a non starter, they can't even get a decent crowd at Gateshead. I'd rather see Keighley than Bradford. Widnes and Leigh are both non starters. In reality, we should merge FC and KR, Leeds and Huddersfield, Saints and Wigan, Warrington and Salford. But that is a business head, not a club pride and history idea.

Re: Twelfth SL club for 2021 : Mon Aug 24, 2020 4:56 pm  

What are the actual chances/possibility of

a) TWP not retaining their status in SL next year

And

b) if that happens, a club to be chosen to take the 12th spot?

I hope as a widnes fan it does happen, or the very minimum somebody replaces Toronto in SL form the championship. Just can’t see them doing it though.

Re: Twelfth SL club for 2021 : Mon Aug 24, 2020 4:58 pm  

IR80 wrote:

]It has to be Tolouse, London has been tried, and failed, Newcastle is a non starter, they can't even get a decent crowd at Gateshead. I'd rather see Keighley than Bradford. Widnes and Leigh are both non starters. In reality, we should merge FC and KR, Leeds and Huddersfield, Saints and Wigan, Warrington and Salford. But that is a business head, not a club pride and history idea.

Why?

Re: Twelfth SL club for 2021 : Mon Aug 24, 2020 5:06 pm  

knockonknockon wrote:

Why?

Because they are both failed SL clubs, time for someone else to get a chance. Nobody would ever chose to go to Leigh or Widnes.

Re: Twelfth SL club for 2021 : Mon Aug 24, 2020 5:17 pm  

IR80 wrote:

Because they are both failed SL clubs, time for someone else to get a chance. Nobody would ever chose to go to Leigh or Widnes.

how do you actually know that?

Re: Twelfth SL club for 2021 : Mon Aug 24, 2020 5:29 pm  

IR80 wrote:

Because they are both failed SL clubs, time for someone else to get a chance. Nobody would ever chose to go to Leigh or Widnes.

Can you name any of the traditional M62 club locations where a player would choose to go to, if it wasn't down to the wages on offer?

The North of England is generally a sh!+hole - Nobody comes to play RL over here for the cultural experience.

By dismissing Leigh or Widnes because nobody would choose to go there, you are basically dismissing places like Castleford, Hull, Huddersfield, Warrington, Wigan, etc, because all those places are similarly depressing places to visit.

Re: Twelfth SL club for 2021 : Mon Aug 24, 2020 5:42 pm  

Dita's Slot Meter wrote:

Can you name any of the traditional M62 club locations where a player would choose to go to, if it wasn't down to the wages on offer?

The North of England is generally a sh!+hole - Nobody comes to play RL over here for the cultural experience.

By dismissing Leigh or Widnes because nobody would choose to go there, you are basically dismissing places like Castleford, Hull, Huddersfield, Warrington, Wigan, etc, because all those places are similarly depressing places to visit.

Hull and Huddersfield have huge history, Warrington, Leigh, Wigan not so much, do you ever travel, understand the places you visit?