Re: Huddersfield Thugby League Club : Sun May 31, 2015 9:05 pm  

Don't think this is really warranted. Bit of a niggly side but if the refs don't deal with it, you find a way.

Would say however I thought Hudds got the rub of the green, I've seen them three times get that rub of the green and not win. They had a big lead in the penalty count today, got lucky with a couple of decisions (Darrell Griffin must be wondering how he got sent off for a borderline high tackle, yet a textbook shoulder charge to Escare's face, and McGilvery tackling higher than a cheech and chong film, penalty sufficient), huge penalty in their favour against Leeds and couldn't win. Teams expecting to win trophies expect to demolish sides when they have a huge penalty count in their favour. Hudds have been struggling to even get over the line.

[Durham Giant]

Re: Huddersfield Thugby League Club : Sun May 31, 2015 9:32 pm  

SmokeyTA wrote:

Don't think this is really warranted. Bit of a niggly side but if the refs don't deal with it, you find a way.

Would say however I thought Hudds got the rub of the green, I've seen them three times get that rub of the green and not win. They had a big lead in the penalty count today, got lucky with a couple of decisions (Darrell Griffin must be wondering how he got sent off for a borderline high tackle, yet a textbook shoulder charge to Escare's face, and McGilvery tackling higher than a cheech and chong film, penalty sufficient), huge penalty in their favour against Leeds and couldn't win. Teams expecting to win trophies expect to demolish sides when they have a huge penalty count in their favour. Hudds have been struggling to even get over the line.

You are wrong on the Escare incident. Wardle when tackling Escare pushes him into Grix. Completely accidental. i guess you were watching at home so would have heard Barrie Mc saying exactly that.

Re: Huddersfield Thugby League Club : Sun May 31, 2015 9:44 pm  

Leaguefan wrote:

That 1st half was a disgrace to the game.
The fact they get away with their dubious tactics is a credit to them and a sad indictment of the game as currently controlled.

Entertainment value 0

Huddersfield could be accused of having a shockingly conservative approach to playing the game. But as for this nonsense about slowing the PTB down more than any other team, what a load of rubbish.

Every team tries to do it. Wigan have been showcased for it by Phil Clarke on boots and all.

If the question is should the ruck be speeded up then definitely yes. Is the game becoming boring as a result of the ruck being slowed, again yes.

The easy solution is to go down to 4 or 6 substitutions then it simply won't happen.

Re: Huddersfield Thugby League Club : Sun May 31, 2015 9:49 pm  

Durham Giant wrote:

You are wrong on the Escare incident. Wardle when tackling Escare pushes him into Grix. Completely accidental. i guess you were watching at home so would have heard Barrie Mc saying exactly that.

I assume most shoulder charges to the head are accidental. You get sent off for it. It might be some mitigation in the disciplinary. But if we aren't sending off shoulder charges which accidentally hit the head, we wont be sending off many, and many who have been sent off will have some valid complaints.

Re: Huddersfield Thugby League Club : Mon Jun 01, 2015 10:34 am  

Anyone want to put me straight on what looked a pretty bad high shot on Escare (?) just before half time? It looked bad in the ground but it got one very brief replay on the big screen and no action taken as play had already restarted. Maybe I'm being one-eyed but it looked every bit as bad as Griffin 's the day before.

Re: Huddersfield Thugby League Club : Mon Jun 01, 2015 10:43 am  

SaleSlim wrote:

Anyone want to put me straight on what looked a pretty bad high shot on Escare (?) just before half time? It looked bad in the ground but it got one very brief replay on the big screen and no action taken as play had already restarted. Maybe I'm being one-eyed but it looked every bit as bad as Griffin 's the day before.

Depends which angle you look at on TV , couple show nothing wrong whilst one shows a shoulder to the face. They did mention Escare got pushed into the player but he still ended up taking a shoulder to the face.

As with most rugby fans , I love watching any game but whenever I see Huddersfield I struggle to be entertained ,all very formula based , drive, drive then to Brough to kick but it works , very efficient and similar to Chelsea at football.

Re: Huddersfield Thugby League Club : Mon Jun 01, 2015 10:55 am  

Andyjc7 wrote:

Depends which angle you look at on TV , couple show nothing wrong whilst one shows a shoulder to the face. They did mention Escare got pushed into the player but he still ended up taking a shoulder to the face.

As with most rugby fans , I love watching any game but whenever I see Huddersfield I struggle to be entertained ,all very formula based , drive, drive then to Brough to kick but it works , very efficient and similar to Chelsea at football.

Don't think it was that one mate. Didn't think it was a shoulder, more a swinging arm and pretty sure he was the only one in the tackle as well. Anyway I Sky +'d it so will watch again when I get home.

Got to say I really enjoyed the weekend and would happily return next year. What does everyone else think? Any other potential options? London too expensive for me, maybe Cardiff again? The Etihad isn't much of a change of scenery so would rather not go back there.

Re: Huddersfield Thugby League Club : Mon Jun 01, 2015 1:12 pm  

Didn't think the Escare incident was deliberate, nor do I think it warranted a red card.
That said, Joel Moon was dismissed in near-identical circs last season and copped a 2-match ban IIRC.

[Jimmythecuckoo]

Re: Huddersfield Thugby League Club : Mon Jun 01, 2015 3:53 pm  

The thing I found oddest about the refereeing was that every time a Catalan player was tackled, Thaler was motioning that they had dived if there was the merest glance asking for a penalty for holding down.

It's as if that was the way he was going to treat us and nothing was going to bend his mind.

Re: Huddersfield Thugby League Club : Tue Jun 02, 2015 12:11 pm  

Jimmythecuckoo wrote:

The thing I found oddest about the refereeing was that every time a Catalan player was tackled, Thaler was motioning that they had dived if there was the merest glance asking for a penalty for holding down.

It's as if that was the way he was going to treat us and nothing was going to bend his mind.

They didn't get the penalties because they do dive about and carry on every time they're tackled. Biggest set of drama queens in SL.