: Sun Mar 29, 2009 4:30 pm  

Code13 wrote:

1. If reasoned argument wont sway you, then you are an idiot, simple as that ( TB has not given any reasoned arguement to suggest to me otherwise.)
2. Hmm, really? Previous posts suggest otherwise. (Read my posts and not one is anti French. Others may have anti French tones but not mine)
3. Dunno, why not ask him, maybe you are upset because Hull lost? (No its generally accepted by Both sets of fans on that night that he was awful)
4. If you actually think that you cant watch many games. ALL refs do that.( Maybe when the attacking team kick the ball and players are ahead of the kicker. Generally speaking a defensive player offside at the PTB is penalised.)
5. All in your opinion. Since it seems you dont have the best grasp of the rules or refereeing, we'll just move on. ( I could say the same of you.)Try watching some games, I mean actually paying attention to them, you might learn the rules. ( see point 5 )

: Sun Mar 29, 2009 4:32 pm  

All this has me wondering what forums would have been like if we'd had them when a certain Mr. Clay was refereeing.

: Sun Mar 29, 2009 4:47 pm  

griffax wrote:

+

& we warned people on here about how bad he was last year when he was given a few SL games..... he sounds like a robot who has been programmed to shout "2 feet"...."hold".... "movement".....

So does that mean that Robert Hicks is a robot? Or Dave Merrick?

They shout "movement" and "hold" all the time when they referee Championship matches. Nothing wrong with doing that at all.

: Sun Mar 29, 2009 5:17 pm  

WireFanatic II wrote:

So does that mean that Robert Hicks is a robot? Or Dave Merrick?

They shout "movement" and "hold" all the time when they referee Championship matches. Nothing wrong with doing that at all.

nothing wrong with that at all, problem I highlighted is that Alibert cannot say much else. Have you ever heard him chatting to players on the run to warn them of something?

A

: Sun Mar 29, 2009 5:22 pm  

griffax wrote:

nothing wrong with that at all, problem I highlighted is that Alibert cannot say much else. Have you ever heard him chatting to players on the run to warn them of something?

Yes.