OK what do you mean by "pure australian"



why isnt someone of islander parents born in australia not a "pure australian"



your own words, explain them

well....if i may jump in....





a 'pure australian' i guess would be an aboriginal chap...though i'm guessing he did'nt mean to use the term 'pure australian' in the racist manner you are trying to make out...





he,as it's already been pointed out,was trying to highlight the difference in the genetic make up between australians of european extraction & australians of pacific island extraction

so now you are a mindreader.

yep...and yes everyone does think you are a 2@

judging by your attempt to defend the guy you made a mess of it.



i mean you were saying the only pure australians were aboriginals, but the poster clearly didnt mean that.



d'oh.

actually i'm guessing when he said this







he means white australians of european decent

spud, leave it for him to explain his thoughts.



you have enough problem explaining your own without worrying about someone else.



So ER, why isnt someone of a polynesian heritage / aboriginal heritage / kiwi heritage who is born in australia a pure australian?

Because their genetic make up is different - do Darren Lockyear and Israel Folau look like they have the same genetic roots? They were probably both born in Australia - but that is the only thing they have in common. Either explain why you think they are the same or accept you are wrong and move on

you lost him at genetic

Sadly not difficult in his case

thanks for explaining it.





yep thats a racist comment.



there is no gene type to be a nationality.



once you are a citizen you are all the same



its good to see you look at someone like darren locker and think "pure australian" and israel folau and dont.



thats exactly the way a racist would differentiate people.

ha ha ha you knob...

thats a pure english comment.

[i

1) Attack The Poster: Instead of addressing the argument that has been made, people using this method attack the person making it instead. This is particularly easy for many delusional people such as Dally. The charge made doesn't even have to be accurate, in fact it's better in some ways if it's off target. That's because the more whacked out the charge is, the more compelled your opponent will feel to spend his time defending himself while you continue to make your points. [/i

differentiating people on the colour of their skin is the definition of racism



to me skin colour doesnt matter, if they are born here they are all the same.

see how you've flipped it round....as usual

google what the term "pure" means.



saying someone is a pure australian if they look like darren lockyer is a racist statement.



clearly if you dont come from that background then you cant be as "pure" as that.



the problem is the word pure you nitwit.

just in case you blanked it out the first time

dont use the term pure australian.



i dont need to keep repeating myself here.



im more than happy ive made my point well enough and that ER has been shown up for what he is.

no it isnt you might want to look up the definition of the term racism if you think knowing the difference between black and white is racism



and nobody mentioned skin colour,



Sonny Bill Williams is a white man of tongan descent,



you brought skin colour into it, he simply said those of polynesian extraction arent genetically pure australian, which is a self fulfilling sentence



unless of course you thought all peoples of polynesion descent are black and that if you arent black you cant be of polynesian descent



you racist bigot



see we can all do it, its not that hard or impressive dally

but he has'nt though...





you've taken 2 words and ran with it dispite being told countless times what he meant..



australian players of pacifc decendants are bigger,faster,strong (in general) than australians with european decendants...





like it or lump it..

Everyone posting - bar you - apparently knew exactly what he meant. You turned it into a pointless argument. If you geniuinly think he meant that as a racist comment you are a PC pillock. I suspect you don't but you just wanted a different argument - you're a c**k.

At the beginning of this thread you were comparing two completely different players, Laurie and Idris, just because they look like they do





You called them 'these types of players'

one day you will get me to bite at one of your posts.



at the moment, despite all your effort, im just not impressed enough.



keep trying.

most australians dont compare between those who are pure and those who arent.



they are all australians.



im picking on those 2 words because they are the ones that ive got a problem with