: Wed Mar 04, 2009 12:48 pm  

Good call although Briers wouldn't get a game imo
They'd look straight at his defensive frailties and say no chance, bit similar to Dobson.

: Wed Mar 04, 2009 12:52 pm  

On paper, play offs easily. Dark horses for the GF, too, I'd say.

: Wed Mar 04, 2009 12:55 pm  

Get an effective defensive structure, which the squad buys into the work ethic. Add a little structure in attack and that team would more than hold it's own in the NRL.

: Wed Mar 04, 2009 12:59 pm  

Dico wrote:

Good call although Briers wouldn't get a game imo
They'd look straight at his defensive frailties and say no chance, bit similar to Dobson.

Agreed. There are some poor defenders in the NRL, such as Benji Marshall, but they tend to be supremely gifted to make up for it.

Interesting Sally Cinammon you use South Sydney as a comparison of playing personnel. If you made a combined team out of their players and ours I believe it might look something like this:

1. Wesser
2. Hicks
3. Gleeson
4. Best
5. King
6. Wing
7. Sandow
8. Asotasi
9. Luke
10.Morley
11.Westwood
12.Fa'alogo
13.Sutton

OK, some of our players are good enough, but in the key positions of 1,6,7,9 and 13 I believe we seriously lack quality and would come somewhere between 11th and 16th in the NRL.

: Wed Mar 04, 2009 1:01 pm  

Monaghan would walk into first grade at Souths.

: Wed Mar 04, 2009 1:11 pm  

sally cinnamon wrote:

Monaghan would walk into first grade at Souths.

Maybe as a hooker interchanging with Isaac Luke, but no way would I have him at 7 over Chris Sandow last year's NRL rookie of the year.

For what its worth I reckon Souths will have a big season, top 4 material for me. I reckon looking at this season's NRL squads we are superior 'on paper' to Canberra, Newcastle, Penrith and maybe North Queensland.

: Wed Mar 04, 2009 1:13 pm  

Would we have the worst first choice full back in the NRL if we were in the comp?

: Wed Mar 04, 2009 1:17 pm  

Robbie Rotten wrote:

Would we have the worst first choice full back in the NRL if we were in the comp?

Mathers?

: Wed Mar 04, 2009 1:19 pm  

Robbie Rotten wrote:

Would we have the worst first choice full back in the NRL if we were in the comp?

One of the worst.

Almost every team has a top drawer full back, the exceptions being Wests Tigers, Canberra, Penrith (although Lachlan Coote is a great prospect) and Parramatta.