Re: Smith Out : Mon Sep 04, 2017 9:27 pm  

Patton will make a very decent half back...in the championship....lower half of the championship. Sorry, i know he's a warrington lad and all that but simply not good enough for upper super league ambitions and never will be.

Re: Smith Out : Mon Sep 04, 2017 9:54 pm  

Well this meeting on Thursday, Agar delivering a video analysis session and Fitzpatrick is in attendance. I'm wondering if the video is going to The three stooges go to market. I know they like to hold back important information till it suits them but they seriously going to have to throw some crumbs out there.

Re: Smith Out : Mon Sep 04, 2017 10:18 pm  

ratticusfinch wrote:

Patton will make a very decent half back...in the championship....lower half of the championship. Sorry, i know he's a warrington lad and all that but simply not good enough for upper super league ambitions and never will be.

It's the Chris Riley syndrome.

Re: Smith Out : Tue Sep 05, 2017 5:31 am  

karetaker wrote:

Well this meeting on Thursday, Agar delivering a video analysis session and Fitzpatrick is in attendance. I'm wondering if the video is going to The three stooges go to market. I know they like to hold back important information till it suits them but they seriously going to have to throw some crumbs out there.

What better way to avoid the issue than to place the elephant in the room eh.

Re: Smith Out : Tue Sep 05, 2017 8:34 am  

Ganson's Optician wrote:

What better way to avoid the issue than to place the elephant in the room eh.

I suppose unless we have prior experience with a super league team, the video analysis session could be pretty dire and be none the wiser.

Re: Smith Out : Tue Sep 05, 2017 9:02 am  

Smith's Brolly wrote:

I suppose unless we have prior experience with a super league team, the video analysis session could be pretty dire and be none the wiser.

Yeah at the end of the video analysis I would say "Well that looks good, so why have we ended up in the qualifiers?"

Re: Smith Out : Tue Sep 05, 2017 9:32 am  

Wires71 wrote:

Yeah at the end of the video analysis I would say "Well that looks good, so why have we ended up in the qualifiers?"

Think I will ask that question.

Re: Smith Out : Tue Sep 05, 2017 9:34 am  

Wires71 wrote:

ratticusfinch wrote:

Patton will make a very decent half back...in the championship....lower half of the championship. Sorry, i know he's a warrington lad and all that but simply not good enough for upper super league ambitions and never will be.

It's the Chris Riley syndrome.

Perhaps Riley & Penny are 2 good examples of our failings as a club this season. Instead of providing these two lads with the necessary coaching to improve their skills, the powers that be resorted to buying in in the form of firstly Hicks, then Michael Monas & King who were great for us when they were over here during our most successful seasons ,but once the Aussie conveyor belt dried up Smith hasn't had the option of buying in players of that calibre. Add to that the forwards from the southern hemisphere who have been & done the job for us only to dwindle gradually in numbers till we are now fielding glorified reserves at times. We bought a man of steel to play hooker a few years back who has been a shadow of his former self since leaving Cas. What we have had for the last 8 years is a coach who was good when the calibre of players we needed could be bought from other clubs, but what we need now is a head coach who can turn raw academy & youth players into great players of the future which i don't think any of our coaches are capable of. Which players have benefitted or improved from their time at the Wire ? Over at Cas ,the coaches have turned unspectacular & average players into an excellent team & all because of their coaching skills ,with game plans to suit every occasion to create overlaps & score tries & make the players look like superstars. On matchdays ,Cas are turning out physically & mentally prepared to win games. This is the era of the skillful coach.

Re: Smith Out : Tue Sep 05, 2017 9:44 am  

ninearches wrote:

Perhaps Riley & Penny are 2 good examples of our failings as a club this season. Instead of providing these two lads with the necessary coaching to improve their skills, the powers that be resorted to buying in in the form of firstly Hicks, then Michael Monas & King who were great for us when they were over here during our most successful seasons ,but once the Aussie conveyor belt dried up Smith hasn't had the option of buying in players of that calibre. Add to that the forwards from the southern hemisphere who have been & done the job for us only to dwindle gradually in numbers till we are now fielding glorified reserves at times. We bought a man of steel to play hooker a few years back who has been a shadow of his former self since leaving Cas. What we have had for the last 8 years is a coach who was good when the calibre of players we needed could be bought from other clubs, but what we need now is a head coach who can turn raw academy & youth players into great players of the future which i don't think any of our coaches are capable of. Which players have benefitted or improved from their time at the Wire ? Over at Cas ,the coaches have turned unspectacular & average players into an excellent team & all because of their coaching skills ,with game plans to suit every occasion to create overlaps & score tries & make the players look like superstars. On matchdays ,Cas are turning out physically & mentally prepared to win games. This is the era of the skillful coach.

100% spot on. When Smith arrived here we had a good squad that just wasn't performing,fair enough him and the coaches we had at the time turned it around. Since we lost them players KIng,Hicks,Morley Carvell, both Monas etc etc, we have never replaced the likes of them, I've seen teams sign some good players and wonder how we missed them. Anyway as you say the quality of players available these days are not as good as those mentioned, so the style of coaching should change to reflect this and if clubs are not looking at Cas as an example I find that to be madness.

Re: Smith Out : Tue Sep 05, 2017 10:01 am  

I think Patton has something and is worth sticking with. I also think he played with a leg injury for a lot of this season. I've always felt him and Ratch would complement each other in the halves.

There was a moment in 2nd half of the Halifax match where he did what a good half should do - attacked the line / ran across it to draw the man and then looked up for a runner to hit - there wasn't one so he kept running, looking for a runner until he reached the sideline and got tackled. All it needed was one runner hitting a good line to take a flat pass. That moment for me summed up his / our season. The halves look awful because they don't have any options to hit.

I remember watching Luke Gale play for London and Dec reminds me a bit of him at that stage - if you put Patton under Powell he'd look like a different player.

Brown has been abject though - the banana kick in broken play with 3 minutes remaining being just the latest low point that could have blown the game for us when it should have been drilled into the corner. Utterly brainless.

I also agree with the comment about coaching versus managing - Smith is (was) a good Manager, we need a coach.