Re: Myler : Thu Aug 26, 2010 3:40 pm  

Mark wrote:

But Myler creates and scores more combined......with ease.

if tomkins played for us there is no way smith would consider dropping him for a final.

Re: Myler : Thu Aug 26, 2010 3:43 pm  

Myler tries/assists per game ratio- 1.38
Tomkins tries/assists per game ratio- 1.15

Myler has missed more tackles and made more errors, but Tomkins has give away 13 more penalties. Both stats can be damaging to a team.

Re: Myler : Thu Aug 26, 2010 3:44 pm  

I'm pretty sure Smith has not based his decision on the selection of the team on a comparison with Sam Tomkins who plays for Wigan - a team completely irrelevant to the final.
It's more likely that Smith will compare the merits of Myler to Clarke, Higham, Monaghan and Briers before making his decision.

Re: Myler : Thu Aug 26, 2010 3:45 pm  

Rogues Gallery wrote:

If you compare Tomkins and Mylers stats, Mylers error and missed tackles are high, which is probably why Smith may leave him out.

Smith has dropped Myler because his stats are not as good as Tomkins.

Re: Myler : Thu Aug 26, 2010 3:49 pm  

Mark wrote:

Myler tries/assists per game ratio- 1.38
Tomkins tries/assists per game ratio- 1.15

Myler has missed more tackles and made more errors, but Tomkins has give away 13 more penalties. Both stats can be damaging to a team.

you can use stats all you like..... as a player tomkins is way ahead of myler at present.

myler has vulnerabilities in his game that tomkins doesnt.

Re: Myler : Thu Aug 26, 2010 3:54 pm  

morleys_deckchair wrote:

you can use stats all you like..... as a player tomkins is way ahead of myler at present.

myler has vulnerabilities in his game that tomkins doesnt.

Just proving to the Wigan fan that stats means jack. He wanted a cheap way of having a dig at Myler an a chance to bum Tomkins up, I was just showing him that stats can be favourable to Myler as well.

Re: Myler : Thu Aug 26, 2010 3:55 pm  

Mark wrote:

Just proving to the Wigan fan that stats means jack. He wanted a cheap way of having a dig at Myler an a chance to bum Tomkins up, I was just showing him that stats can be favourable to Myler as well.

fair enough

Re: Myler : Thu Aug 26, 2010 3:56 pm  

manoa thompsons knees wrote:

Smith has dropped Myler because his stats are not as good as Tomkins.

Nope, cause they're better.

Re: Myler : Thu Aug 26, 2010 4:15 pm  

Mark wrote:

Myler tries/assists per game ratio- 1.38
Tomkins tries/assists per game ratio- 1.15

Tomkins has been playing at fullback for a while so i'd expect his assist stats to drop below that of a scrum half, also when he played at half back he was an individual type half back like Eastmond that didn't do assists that often.

Myler should have more asissits as he rarely looks to take the line on, he'd rather pass it then look for a possible opening.

Re: Myler : Thu Aug 26, 2010 8:18 pm  

Mark wrote:

Just proving to the Wigan fan that stats means jack. He wanted a cheap way of having a dig at Myler an a chance to bum Tomkins up, I was just showing him that stats can be favourable to Myler as well.

#

I wasn't having a cheap dig at Myler, just explaining the reasons why Smith may not select him.

Last year when Myler was at Salford, Shaun Wane in his pre match address to the spectators in the South Stand bar (prior to the Wigan v Salford Cup game) openly stated that Wigan would target Mylers weakness in defence and they did. So much that McRae moved Myler to the wing position at times in the game to allow other players to defend in Mylers position.