[Bullseye]

Re: LCTV Commentary : Tue Mar 26, 2019 10:43 am  

Both sides seemed to incur his wrath on Sunday but we seemed to take it in turns. To be fair both sides were standing offside all day and lying in the ruck or trying to milk a penalty at the PTB. He had a job on trying to keep the game flowing with that going on. There were some baffling decisions but you always get a couple.

Re: LCTV Commentary : Tue Mar 26, 2019 12:10 pm  

There is a picture on the Leigh Facebook page of Jonny Pownall catching the Bradford penalty that he was binned for. Hes not even close to being in touch, you have to question what the linesman has seen?

No wonder Jonny was annoyed (I know he should have kept his mouth shut)

Re: LCTV Commentary : Tue Mar 26, 2019 4:02 pm  

I have just captured the moment JP catches the ball here.

Re: LCTV Commentary : Tue Mar 26, 2019 4:09 pm  

Here's a video clip

Here's a video clip

Re: LCTV Commentary : Tue Mar 26, 2019 5:37 pm  

Clearly well inside the line and Bradford scored the next set I think. Anyway we lost.

Re: LCTV Commentary : Wed Mar 27, 2019 1:43 am  

Alan wrote:

There appeared to be a lot of subjectivity on the part of the ref. I know there is always a degree of interpretation on the ref's part, but those two clear examples on Sunday. (i.e. the injured Bradford lad pointed out by the Leigh players, and the ref rightly stopped the game. Then Adamson, who was also clearly injured, but penalised when he didn't roll away. He then required lengthy treatment before he could resume.) Like all other decisions, consistency is required.

Gaining consistency must start with interpreting the " Laws of the game" until that's addressed, I'm not sure what laws Officials are following because it certainly isn't what is written.

They still have laws of the game written that don't support the on field decisions of the Ref. They still have the laws that the PTB should be heeled back,and also the attacking player after being tackled should wait until the ruck is clear before the PTB.

Now if we want consistency, surely the " Laws of the game" require adapting so all Refs/Players/Coaches and fans are all on the same page.

I'm not saying its wrong to have a quick PTB and roll it through without using the heel or players not clearing the ruck. But the laws of the game cannot be followed without clarification for all.

It must be a nightmare for Refs.

Re: LCTV Commentary : Wed Mar 27, 2019 11:56 am  

The laws need updating to cover what is actually happening in various aspects of the game. The play the ball is the current area of ridicule, the referees should have the discretion to punish the real offenders in the situation, they are regularly ignoring the ball carrier moving off the mark and penalising the defender. They must be following an instruction to penalise the defender.

[Bullseye]

Re: LCTV Commentary : Wed Mar 27, 2019 4:23 pm  

To be fair to refs the PTB is such a mess you can penalise both ball carrier and defender a lot of the time. On Sunday there were many cases of the ball carrier deliberately locking in a defender or moving off the mark and the defender deliberately lying in the way to slow things down. All sides are guilty of it.

I’m not really sure what you do about it other than adopt the two refs system. Trouble is we haven’t enough refs to do that over here.

Re: LCTV Commentary : Thu Mar 28, 2019 2:35 am  

reffy wrote:

The laws need updating to cover what is actually happening in various aspects of the game. The play the ball is the current area of ridicule, the referees should have the discretion to punish the real offenders in the situation, they are regularly ignoring the ball carrier moving off the mark and penalising the defender. They must be following an instruction to penalise the defender.

Then that contradicts the laws of the game, hence inconsistency. Then again if the laws of the game are obsolete and instruction takes precedence over those laws! What laws is the sport following?

Bullseye wrote:

To be fair to refs the PTB is such a mess you can penalise both ball carrier and defender a lot of the time. On Sunday there were many cases of the ball carrier deliberately locking in a defender or moving off the mark and the defender deliberately lying in the way to slow things down. All sides are guilty of it.

I’m not really sure what you do about it other than adopt the two refs system. Trouble is we haven’t enough refs to do that over here.

What laws of the game do new up and coming Referees have to follow? Laws of the game or instruction that contradicts those laws?

Yes, all sides are guilty of it. Its something that has been created and manipulated, but now we have Refs following instruction, not the laws of the game.

How can you complain about Refs/ Officials when the laws of the game have never been updated/adapted to todays modern game?

Re: LCTV Commentary : Mon Apr 01, 2019 8:07 pm  

when will the sheffield highlights be on l.c.t.v.