Re: Last disallowed Try Question : Mon Aug 09, 2021 11:22 pm  

Keiththered wrote:

What has age got to do with it? He is a Leigh player the same as the other 16. Players don’t go into a tackle thinking I’ll take this easy as he’s only a young kid. Kendall was inconsistent Sidlow should have been in the bin for head high on Simms. The rovers head highs were no worse and both resulted in sin bins. Placed 75 minutes with 16 players 18 minutes with someone in the bin, 2 of which reduced us to 11 and you still could not win.

You've spent a bit more than us on your squad, good luck in the Grand Final. p.s 11 men for 2 minutes, you drama queen.

Re: Last disallowed Try Question : Mon Aug 09, 2021 11:51 pm  

Vancouver Leyther wrote:

Thanks Reffy, so the HKR try should have been disallowed for the same reason.
Very frustrating.

Crooks put them all onside, the ref sends it up to check the knock on. One he awards on field as a try after consultation with his touch judges, no call from the ref to any player to stay onside after Lawler kicks. Hoods was straight forward offside. The ref for me was correct in both decisions. You can’t be judging if someone is encroaching 10m when the fullback just played them all onside.

It got sent up as a try.

Re: Last disallowed Try Question : Tue Aug 10, 2021 6:20 pm  

atomic wrote:

Crooks put them all onside, the ref sends it up to check the knock on. One he awards on field as a try after consultation with his touch judges, no call from the ref to any player to stay onside after Lawler kicks. Hoods was straight forward offside. The ref for me was correct in both decisions. You can’t be judging if someone is encroaching 10m when the fullback just played them all onside.

It got sent up as a try.

Crooks cannot put anyone who was in front of him onside who are within the 10, the only person who can put people back onside is the kicker of the ball which clearly he didn't. The try should of been disallowed by the rules of the game, although it's one rule I hate as even though within the 10 he has no outcome on the play at all.

Re: Last disallowed Try Question : Tue Aug 10, 2021 7:29 pm  

Budgiezilla wrote:

You've spent a bit more than us on your squad, good luck in the Grand Final. p.s 11 men for 2 minutes, you drama queen.

I’m not sure about the point you are trying to make. Yes we probably have spent a bit more on our squad. It is reflected in the table. To attract quality players you have to pay accordingly. It is however well known that to get away from the foot of the table you have to pay over the odds to attract players. Otherwise the only players you will get will be those not wanted by other clubs. Due to Toronto dropping out we finished bottom last year. How many of our 2020 squad did you sign?

Re: Last disallowed Try Question : Tue Aug 10, 2021 8:16 pm  

Wayne Buxton wrote:

Crooks cannot put anyone who was in front of him onside who are within the 10, the only person who can put people back onside is the kicker of the ball which clearly he didn't. The try should of been disallowed by the rules of the game, although it's one rule I hate as even though within the 10 he has no outcome on the play at all.

Correct.

Re: Last disallowed Try Question : Wed Aug 11, 2021 12:53 pm  

Keiththered wrote:

Not if the proposed system is introduced. You’ll have to wait until the end of 2022 season for that pleasure, it will only delay the inevitable. I’m afraid I cannot see you finishing 10th out of fourteen. You will need almost a new team. Effort will not be enough you will need skill as well. The likes of Joel Tomkins will not be enough.

Keith, we will have almost a new team as this team was almost solely recruited for the Championship - next season will be interesting due to the great financial position we will be in compared to our rivals.

On the game, you were gifted numerous helping hands by a very poor official which kept you camped in our 30m area most of the first half. We had the ball in your 20m 3 times scoring twice, as soon as we started to get some position you panicked and despite the decision of the jokiciary the head shots were straight reds imo.

You rode your luck, are in the T6 and I look forward to a much more even match up in 2022 when you will be fighting to make the 10 like ourselves.

Re: Last disallowed Try Question : Wed Aug 11, 2021 12:55 pm  

atomic wrote:

Crooks put them all onside, the ref sends it up to check the knock on. One he awards on field as a try after consultation with his touch judges, no call from the ref to any player to stay onside after Lawler kicks. Hoods was straight forward offside. The ref for me was correct in both decisions. You can’t be judging if someone is encroaching 10m when the fullback just played them all onside.

It got sent up as a try.

Thats a brilliant example of total buzzcox, one of the best ever imo

Re: Last disallowed Try Question : Wed Aug 11, 2021 1:45 pm  

maurice wrote:

Keith, we will have almost a new team as this team was almost solely recruited for the Championship - next season will be interesting due to the great financial position we will be in compared to our rivals.

On the game, you were gifted numerous helping hands by a very poor official which kept you camped in our 30m area most of the first half. We had the ball in your 20m 3 times scoring twice, as soon as we started to get some position you panicked and despite the decision of the jokiciary the head shots were straight reds imo.

You rode your luck, are in the T6 and I look forward to a much more even match up in 2022 when you will be fighting to make the 10 like ourselves.

You say “ we will have almost a new team as this team was almost solely recruited for the Championship - next season will be interesting due to the great financial position we will be in compared to our rivals.”

Assuming you are not relegated where are all these quality players you will need coming from? When at this point none of us know what format will be in place in 2022 how do you know you will be in a great financial position compared to your rivals? You don’t even know who will in SL next year. Looking at the possibilities, Toulouse look in great shape and well supported financially. I suspect you would struggle to beat them this year never mind next whichever division you are both in.

Re: Last disallowed Try Question : Wed Aug 11, 2021 3:43 pm  

Cokey wrote:

Correct.

Seconded.

Re: Last disallowed Try Question : Thu Aug 12, 2021 10:48 am  

For information: I was sat right in line with the first half try by Minikin which resulted from Brad Takairangi being a couple of yards off side when the kick went up. The touch judge must have seen that but took no action forcing the ref to send it up as a try. Sadly, despite their multitude of cameras, Sky did not have one on Takairangi. Also, the next try resulted from a blatant forward pass a couple of plays earlier. I'm tempted to ask what is the point of the touch judges if they simply abrogate their responsibilities especially if they think there's a camera on it.