: Sun Mar 15, 2009 10:25 pm  

Danril wrote:

No consistency, is there.

Watched the replay today and the number of turtles and leg grabs Cas did and weren't penalised for is annoying. We did it, we got pinged. They did, but...

Also watch McGoldrick messing around with Cudjoe near the line after he'd made his break. then Cudjoe does exactly the same but gets 10mins. Maybe Nathan should complain about Ganson like Daniel Anderson did about Smith(I think). Saints never had him again then the first game of the season when Anderson had gone, Saints get Smith.

: Sun Mar 15, 2009 11:05 pm  

Happened against Hull too, watched replay on sky when got home and when Aspy was carried into touch the ref had clearly shouted "one" as in 1st tackle (he wasn't tackled but that is another argument).

The Hull players then picked him up and the ref called "play on"? they carried him into touch, now if the ref had not shouted "one" I would have no qualms at all, the problem is he did and Hull shoiuld have been penalised, I guarentee other way round and we would have been pinged.

Need some consistency!! ping us but ping em all or don't ping anyone.

: Mon Mar 16, 2009 7:50 am  

PONNER wrote:

Also watch McGoldrick messing around with Cudjoe near the line after he'd made his break. then Cudjoe does exactly the same but gets 10mins. Maybe Nathan should complain about Ganson like Daniel Anderson did about Smith(I think). Saints never had him again then the first game of the season when Anderson had gone, Saints get Smith.

Because you scored of the next play he got away with, ref should have played advantage and after the score, binned RM, at least thats the way i see it.

: Mon Mar 16, 2009 8:34 am  

Think the Millennium Magic weekends show the inconsistency of refereeing up best where you sit through 3 games and each game is penalised differently depending on the ref what one team get away with in one game is penalised in another and vie severs er

: Mon Mar 16, 2009 10:51 am  

has brownie been outspoken

: Mon Mar 16, 2009 11:35 am  

I think are dicipline is awful and we need tpo sort it out really quick.

: Mon Mar 16, 2009 12:01 pm  

think matterson should sort himself out, on out about us around their heads all the time yet the worst example of this was in the last minute when huby took walshs head , also noticed today in league express discipinary hearings from last week that guess what as well as the giants players accused of grapples last week a cas player was also up for it, double standards me thinks, even if there was grapple tackles on saturday which having now seen the game 3 times still not seen them it still smacks of sour grapes.

: Mon Mar 16, 2009 12:09 pm  

goodie wrote:

think matterson should sort himself out, on out about us around their heads all the time yet the worst example of this was in the last minute when huby took walshs head , also noticed today in league express discipinary hearings from last week that guess what as well as the giants players accused of grapples last week a cas player was also up for it, double standards me thinks, even if there was grapple tackles on saturday which having now seen the game 3 times still not seen them it still smacks of sour grapes.

: Mon Mar 16, 2009 12:14 pm  

I think it's safe to say Matterson was upset at not being able to win with all that ball they had.

What I noticed once or twice was Hudson getting involved and pushing our man back down on the tackle and then holding his hands out appealing for a penalty. Sneaky!

: Mon Mar 16, 2009 12:40 pm  

goodie wrote:

think matterson should sort himself out, on out about us around their heads all the time yet the worst example of this was in the last minute when huby took walshs head , also noticed today in league express discipinary hearings from last week that guess what as well as the giants players accused of grapples last week a cas player was also up for it, double standards me thinks, even if there was grapple tackles on saturday which having now seen the game 3 times still not seen them it still smacks of sour grapes.

very true,paul