: Sun Feb 15, 2009 7:12 pm  

Smith has never won Dally M.

: Sun Feb 15, 2009 7:21 pm  

PaulM wrote:

Smith has never won Dally M.

Dally M 'Rookie' 2005.

: Mon Feb 16, 2009 1:17 am  

PaulM wrote:

Smith has never won Dally M.

tes he has he won dally m rookie of the year, which in my books puts him up there, i know he had alot of trouble of the field over in aussie, but you gotta admit his first game was poor this season but the stuff he put on against hull was class i just hope for this lads sake that he keeps it goin and proves a hell of alot of people wrong

: Mon Feb 16, 2009 1:30 am  

Legend That Sorts It wrote:

tes he has he won dally m rookie of the year, which in my books puts him up there, i know he had alot of trouble of the field over in aussie, but you gotta admit his first game was poor this season but the stuff he put on against hull was class i just hope for this lads sake that he keeps it goin and proves a hell of alot of people wrong

I actually saw some nice touches against Wakey with ball in hand but i felt his options were lacking especially in the first half when he attacked down the left. He created time and space but had nobody to use it.

Also thinking about it he attacked on the left at times but defended on the right which for a player with poor defence is unusual.

: Mon Feb 16, 2009 10:09 am  

cracks me up how some people on this topic are now saying, 'Oh Smith played good... I thought he played good against Wakefield aswell' ... Just shows how two faced people are, last week he was poop, shouldn't be on the pitch. They were calling him rotten on this forum. Same goes for Bailey aswell, calling him poop and then he goes and scores against Hull, 'Oh Bailey's quality... i've always said it!' ... Typical Wigan fans.

: Mon Feb 16, 2009 10:31 am  

LordLoveRocket87 wrote:

cracks me up how some people on this topic are now saying, 'Oh Smith played good... I thought he played good against Wakefield aswell' ... Just shows how two faced people are, last week he was poop, shouldn't be on the pitch. They were calling him rotten on this forum. Same goes for Bailey aswell, calling him poop and then he goes and scores against Hull, 'Oh Bailey's quality... i've always said it!' ... Typical Wigan fans.

Are you a troll in disguise or what, because you sound increasingly like one?

The above is an absolute pile of unfiltered sh*te.

Get off your high horse and then get over yourself.

You haven't taken a census of Wigan fans' views. You're responding to a couple of people's personal opinions, and then tarring everyone with the same brush.

Very few, if any, have doubted Smith's ability. They've questioned his motivation, but not his talent. Equally few have decided that Phil Bailey is now the best thing since sliced bread simply because he's (finally) scored a try. Most still expect and hope that his contract won't be renewed.

I've seen most of your posts so far, and personally I think you're in the wrong place. This is a forum for open discussion about Wigan RL. Some people on here have their own agenda, but most are fanatical fans who've earned the right to debate the goods and bads of their club. I don't like negativity for it's own sake, as I've said many times. But if you're going to blow a gasket every time fans make observations on the team that don't chime with your "everything is great at Wigan, because to say otherwise is being disloyal" mentality, then coming on here regularly is not going to do your health any good.

: Mon Feb 16, 2009 10:41 am  

Cruncher wrote:

Are you a troll in disguise or what, because you sound increasingly like one?

The above is an absolute pile of unfiltered sh*te.

Get off your high horse and then get over yourself.

You haven't taken a census of Wigan fans' views. You're responding to a couple of people's personal opinions, and then tarring everyone with the same brush.

Very few, if any, have doubted Smith's ability. They've questioned his motivation, but not his talent. Equally few have decided that Phil Bailey is now the best thing since sliced bread simply because he's (finally) scored a try. Most still expect and hope that his contract won't be renewed.

I've seen most of your posts so far, and personally I think you're in the wrong place. This is a forum for open discussion about Wigan RL. Some people on here have their own agenda, but most are fanatical fans who've earned the right to debate the goods and bads of their club. I don't like negativity for it's own sake, as I've said many times. But if you're going to blow a gasket every time fans make observations on the team that don't chime with your "everything is great at Wigan, because to say otherwise is being disloyal" mentality, then coming on here regularly is not going to do your health any good.

For one, I said 'some people.'

Secondly, stop stalking me you weirdo.

: Mon Feb 16, 2009 10:51 am  

LordLoveRocket87 wrote:

For one, I said 'some people.'

Secondly, stop stalking me you weirdo.

Stalking you?

I'm replying to your post, or are people not allowed to do that unless it's to make a point you agree with?

You really are in the wrong place, kiddo.