: Sat Mar 07, 2009 9:38 pm  

jonh wrote:

How has Noble managed to look capable of "taking us to the dance", realistically he has not, and when we have got to the enterance of this dance, we have been firmly sent packing by the door staff.

A cup semi final (that we lost thanks to Maurice & Dave)
2 Final Eliminators. last year, we had the chances but were left with a bit much to do.
Two third place finishes makes us much more successful than Bradford, hence the difference.

: Sat Mar 07, 2009 9:43 pm  

AJ wrote:

A cup semi final (that we lost thanks to Maurice & Dave)
2 Final Eliminators. last year, we had the chances but were left with a bit much to do.
Two third place finishes makes us much more successful than Bradford, hence the difference.

How do you blame the Cats loss on Maurice and Dave and do you credit them with getting us there in the first place?

We are not more successfull than Bradford, you have to have success to be successfull, what we have done is consistently perform worse than them but finish higher in the table.

I think both Noble and McNammara should be judged at the end of there time at the clubs they coach, but lets not each have our own opinions on them.

I would say McNammara is now in the position Noble was last week, as i said earlier if his players react and they smash there next opponents will he suddenly become some sort of guru?

: Sat Mar 07, 2009 9:49 pm  

AJ wrote:

A cup semi final (that we lost thanks to Maurice & Dave)
2 Final Eliminators. last year, we had the chances but were left with a bit much to do.
Two third place finishes makes us much more successful than Bradford, hence the difference.

2 C/cup finals...1 win and 1 defeat.
1 G/F appearance and defeat
1 Play off defeat to you.
All in 4 years

Does that make us more successful than Bradford and you?

: Sat Mar 07, 2009 9:52 pm  

fc baldy wrote:

2 C/cup finals...1 win and 1 defeat.
1 G/F appearance and defeat
1 Play off defeat to you.
All in 4 years

Does that make us more successful than Bradford and you?

Exactly. How can a team be successful without actually winning anything?

: Sat Mar 07, 2009 9:54 pm  

jonh wrote:

Exactly. How can a team be successful without actually winning anything?

Blows the "big 4" myth out of the water as well......when was the last time both won owt or appeared in a final.

Not having a pop at you lot mate...just think its a good point.

: Sat Mar 07, 2009 10:03 pm  

fc baldy wrote:

2 C/cup finals...1 win and 1 defeat.
1 G/F appearance and defeat
1 Play off defeat to you.
All in 4 years

Does that make us more successful than Bradford and you?

Yes, it does, because you won a trophy, I didnt say we were successful, I said we were closer to success than Bradford.

: Sat Mar 07, 2009 10:03 pm  

jonh wrote:

How do you blame the Cats loss on Maurice and Dave and do you credit them with getting us there in the first place?

Salary cap.

: Sat Mar 07, 2009 10:07 pm  

I can only agree with all that, really dissappointed with tonight's performance. The only thing I dispute is that we have a leader in Morro.

: Sat Mar 07, 2009 11:28 pm  

AJ wrote:

Salary cap.

Why fail to answer the question?

rl : Sat Mar 07, 2009 11:35 pm  

Bradford have fallen a long way since the days of the awesome foursome with Henry & Robbie at half back.
They were scary then.