Barry eaton was a fine player in his pomp, be we got him at the end of his career when his "legs had gone"
Chris Robinson played at the height of Cougarmania, was a fine organiser and awesome defender but lacked the verve in attack displayed by Appleby. Chris would never have made the play that Appleby carved up Huddersfield with to put Woody under the posts at Old Trafford.
For me, the complete scrum half was Nathan Antonik. Hard as nails, good rugby brain and the acceleration to take him through the line. When he came back to play in the testimonial match he still looked as good as anything we've seen down here over the last few years.
