Re: Brough and Cash for Cooke? : Sun Jan 03, 2010 7:40 pm  

J.T wrote:

Robinson is gash.

would not pay him out in washers

Re: Brough and Cash for Cooke? : Sun Jan 03, 2010 7:44 pm  

Would rather take Brown myself, just the sort of player Kear could work wonders on, would have Brough before the both of them.

Re: Brough and Cash for Cooke? : Sun Jan 03, 2010 7:46 pm  

see id take brough going for brown and cash and see if brown could play stand off again with BJ (clubscapegoat).

intrestingly in brough stays and "informed thinking" is hes leaving watch how quickly he becomes official club scapegoat!

Re: Brough and Cash for Cooke? : Sun Jan 03, 2010 7:49 pm  

chapster wrote:

see id take brough going for brown and cash and see if brown could play stand off again with BJ (clubscapegoat).

intrestingly in brough stays and "informed thinking" is hes leaving watch how quickly he becomes official club scapegoat!

Scapegoat or not I think even BJ's biggest fan wouldn't back him at 7.

Re: Brough and Cash for Cooke? : Sun Jan 03, 2010 7:53 pm  

if brough plays like he did boxing day then he will deserve the scape goat tag, time will tell.

Re: Brough and Cash for Cooke? : Sun Jan 03, 2010 7:56 pm  

J.T wrote:

Scapegoat or not I think even BJ's biggest fan wouldn't back him at 7.

well to be fair it where he played his best when here last!

Re: Brough and Cash for Cooke? : Sun Jan 03, 2010 7:58 pm  

i think if broughy does leave you will really strugle to replace him with a player even half as good unless you go to oz and pay out a fortune, but on the other side of that if you do list him now it will probbably just upset the camp and to be honest every club he has played at including you now if rumours are to be blieved it has not ended well so in my opinion it would be a big risk for any club to come and pay a big fee for him but if he goes on a free transfer he is much less of a risk to a new employer and you might just get a good season out of him if he knows he is already sorted at the giants for next season.

Re: Brough and Cash for Cooke? : Sun Jan 03, 2010 8:01 pm  

chapster wrote:

well to be fair it where he played his best when here last!

And his worst.
His only option is stand off for me as a slightly better Rooney/Martin.

Re: Brough and Cash for Cooke? : Sun Jan 03, 2010 8:03 pm  

So do we go back to the title of the thread?
with or without the cash.

Re: Brough and Cash for Cooke? : Sun Jan 03, 2010 8:06 pm  

PHe wrote:

So do we go back to the title of the thread?
with or without the cash.

sounds like that deals a non starter now with or without cash.